The top reported proficiency rate is 74% in Science. The lowest is 70% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Madison Elementary School
Madison Elementary School is a regular public school serving pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in Middletown, Ohio. It sits in Madison Local, a district that covers a mid-sized city with deep industrial heritage positioned between Cincinnati and Dayton. The school draws families from a community in modest growth, with a downtown revitalization underway and new residential development moving toward the I-75 corridor where newer school facilities have been sited.
The school's academic profile shows solid performance across the tested grades and subjects. In the most recent state testing cycle, the school's students reached proficiency in reading and language arts at a rate above the midpoint among districts in Butler County. Mathematics proficiency was somewhat lower but still respectable, and science performance was the strongest of the three. The school's overall proficiency index places it above the midpoint relative to other districts in the county. Notably, only one year of state testing data is available in the system, so trend analysis is not possible.
The student body is relatively homogeneous, with the large majority of families identifying as white. About half the enrolled students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which reflects mixed income levels across the attendance area. The school serves roughly the enrollment you would expect for a full-service elementary building at this grade span in a district this size. Special education enrollment and English learner counts were not available from the data provided.
The broader Madison Local context is important for families considering this school. The district passed a renewal levy in November 2025 after a closely contested May election that had failed by a small margin. That earlier failure triggered real cuts: high school busing was eliminated, activity fees rose sharply, and supplemental teaching and coaching positions were cut. The renewal, which extends a property-tax levy the district has relied on for over a decade, restores busing and reduces fees. Families weighing Madison should understand that the district's operating funding remains tied to this levy structure, and the renewal extends commitment through roughly the next decade.
Middletown itself is experiencing steady downtown revitalization centered on the restored Sorg Opera House and walkable Main Street, which has drawn young professionals and artists. Civic anchors include the MidPointe Library's main branch downtown and the Butler County transit system. Housing values in the area are modest relative to national benchmarks and have appreciated modestly year over year. Most residents live in mid-20th-century single-family homes, though new townhome subdivisions are moving forward on the city's east side near the interstate. The city issued a request for developers to reimagine several long-vacant downtown sites in late 2025, signaling ongoing investment.
Madison Elementary occupies the regular school space within this context. The school's location on the city's edge near Alexandria Road reflects the broader shift of newer school facilities away from the historic downtown core, where the last historical school building was demolished in 2021. For families, Madison offers a neighborhood elementary school serving an established residential area, with state test results that meet a reasonable bar and a student composition that is predominantly white and about half economically disadvantaged. No information was available on curriculum offerings, instructional approach, special programs, staffing, or day-to-day school culture.
See more original research from School Decision →