Original Research by School Decision on Crestview High School
Crestview High School is a small-enrollment public high school serving grades nine through twelve in Columbiana, Ohio, a town in the northeastern part of the state between Cleveland and Pittsburgh. The school sits in a district undergoing substantial physical transformation as a new consolidated PreK-12 campus takes shape, reshaping both the immediate learning environment and long-term financial obligations for families in the area.
The academic picture shows solid strength in English language arts and science. Students score well across reading and science proficiency measures. Performance in social studies is also strong. Mathematics proficiency sits at a lower level than the other core subjects, a gap that a parent investigating the school might want to explore further with the school to understand what support or pathway options exist for students needing additional math work.
Only one year of state assessment data is available, so longer-term trends cannot be assessed. The school serves approximately 340 students across all four high school grades, with enrollment fairly evenly distributed. About one-third of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is predominantly white, with very limited racial and ethnic diversity; the available enrollment data does not break out the specific numbers for English learners or students with Individualized Education Programs, so a parent seeking that information should ask the school directly.
The school is part of Crestview Local School District, which is in the midst of a major capital project. A new consolidated PreK-12 campus on Crestview Road is under construction and scheduled to open for the 2026-27 school year. This facility will bring all grades into a single building with flexible learning spaces, pod-style academic areas, a new competition gymnasium, and a kindergarten wing. The district funded this project through state support and a local bond issue that voters approved, which is being collected at a specified mill rate outside the baseline 10-mill limitation for up to a set number of years. Families considering a move to the district should understand that this bond obligation will extend for decades and will be part of their property tax bills.
A separate development worth noting: the district also built a standalone athletic complex from its general fund because the new consolidated school does not include locker rooms or weight rooms. This facility, which includes retractable batting cages and wrestling practice space, serves as the hub for student athletic training across all sports and is used for physical education classes.
Columbiana itself is a small city with an older population and an established character anchored by a walkable downtown with a historic roundabout at Main Street and Park Avenue, small shops, and a public library. Growth is concentrated in the Firestone Farms development near State Routes 7 and 14, a newly built residential and commercial area with golf-course homes and a town center. The city recently created a community reinvestment area that offers property tax abatement on new construction for a limited time, which has accelerated housing development. Home values in the area reflect a market below the national benchmark and at a price-to-income ratio that is favorable compared to national averages. The economy is mixed, with small manufacturing, healthcare (Salem Regional Medical Center operates a clinic locally and is building a new facility), and retail. Many residents also commute to Youngstown or Pittsburgh for work.
The housing market and civic stability offer a different character than a growing suburban district might; this is a small-town high school in a community that has stabilized after decades of regional economic challenge and is selectively growing through deliberate development rather than sprawl. A parent considering this school should understand both the academic profile as it stands and the substantial capital investment the district is making in new infrastructure, which will reshape the physical learning environment within the next couple of years.
See more original research from School Decision →