Original Research by School Decision on Col Crawford High School
Col Crawford High School is a small public high school in Crestline, a tight-knit village in Crawford County anchored by manufacturing, freight rail, and health care. The school sits within the village footprint rather than on an outlying campus, part of the Colonel Crawford Local district that serves grades pre-K through 12.
The school enrolls a small cohort across grades nine through twelve, with a slight bulge in the ninth and tenth grades. The population is predominantly white, with small numbers of Hispanic and multiracial students and almost no Asian, Black, or Native American enrollment. About one in five students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating a modest but meaningful share of economic hardship in the catchment.
On state assessments most recently available, the school shows uneven performance. Students perform well in English language arts and science, with proficiency near three-quarters of the student body, and the proficiency rate in social studies is notably strong. Mathematics proficiency, however, sits notably lower, around one in two students. One data point does not show a trend, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about whether math performance has been improving or holding steady and what supports are in place. The school's performance metrics on graduation rate and chronic absenteeism were not available in the data provided.
Crestline itself is a small village experiencing modest recent population decline after a period of growth driven by property-tax abatement for residential construction and renovation. The community has a visible civic life organized around the small downtown, with seasonal events, a library, parks, and a municipal pool within walkable distance. Most residents own their homes and the population skews older. Housing values are well below both state and national benchmarks, making home purchase and rental affordable by national standards. The local economy offers employment in manufacturing, rail freight operations, health care, and retail, though the scale is small-town.
The school itself serves a population with strong family ties to place. Program offerings and course breadth were not detailed in the available data, so a family considering this school should ask directly about AP availability, career pathways, and extracurricular breadth. The district operates on a longstanding income tax rather than a new property levy, and no recent district-wide curriculum changes or governance shifts were reported.
For families already rooted in Crestline or nearby, Col Crawford offers a small-school environment with known peer networks and a school building woven into village life rather than set apart. The math performance gap warrants direct inquiry into instruction and support. For families considering relocation to the area for the school, the low housing costs and small-town character cut both ways: affordability is genuine, but the scale and economic base are modest, and the school's overall academic profile sits below the strongest urban and suburban alternatives in the state.
See more original research from School Decision →