The top reported proficiency rate is 72% in Social studies. The lowest is 46% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Herbert Mills Elementary School
Herbert Mills Elementary School serves kindergarten through fifth grade in Reynoldsburg, a suburban city east of Columbus in Franklin County. The school has a student population reflective of the city's demographic diversity: a substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the student body is roughly evenly split among Black, white, and multiracial students, with smaller Asian and Hispanic populations represented as well.
On state assessments given to grades three through five, Herbert Mills students show modest proficiency. In English language arts, about half of tested students reached proficiency. Mathematics proficiency is slightly lower. Science proficiency is stronger, with roughly three-fifths of tested students meeting the standard. Against other elementary schools in Franklin County, Herbert Mills's overall proficiency index places it below the midpoint, meaning there are comparable schools in the county performing at higher levels. The school participates fully in state testing, with no participation gaps.
The school has experienced enrollment growth in recent years. It currently serves roughly four hundred students distributed fairly evenly across the six grade levels, with slightly larger classes in the upper elementary grades. The campus is located on Retton Road, part of the district's footprint of separated suburban school buildings rather than a downtown-centered arrangement.
The broader district context matters for families considering Herbert Mills. Reynoldsburg City Schools faced a significant budget shock in late 2024 when voters rejected a five-year operating levy, triggering substantial cuts in the 2025-26 school year. The district eliminated roughly fifty teaching positions, removed elementary assistant principal roles, cut two school resource officers, and delayed maintenance and technology updates. Families should expect these reduced service levels as the operating baseline. Athletic participation fees have been raised as well. The district has indicated no plans for a new levy in the near term. Additionally, the district is redistricting for 2025-26 to rebalance enrollment across buildings; families may find school assignments changing from what they were previously.
Reynoldsburg itself is growing rapidly, with substantial new residential development underway and a clear trajectory toward adding thousands of housing units. The city sits within the Columbus metropolitan area and has invested in downtown revitalization along Main Street, though the school system operates on separated suburban campuses. State employment, retail headquarters like Victoria's Secret, and regional commercial activity shape the local economy and housing market.
A parent may want to look into the school's response to the budget cuts and how staffing reductions have affected classroom sizes, specialist services, and support staff presence, since these will shape the day-to-day experience for students.
See more original research from School Decision →