The top reported proficiency rate is 93% in Social studies. The lowest is 73% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Scioto Darby Elementary School
Scioto Darby Elementary School is a regular public elementary school serving kindergarten through fifth grade in Hilliard, a fast-growing suburb west of Columbus in Franklin County. The school enrolls a small to mid-sized student body with a residential catchment that draws from the Scioto Darby Road area.
The school's academic performance on state testing shows proficiency across core subjects. In reading and language arts, students perform in the mid-range for their tested grades. Mathematics proficiency sits just below reading. Science is the strongest subject, with students performing meaningfully higher than in reading or math. These results position the school's overall proficiency in the top quartile relative to other elementary schools in Franklin County, a strong showing that reflects solid foundational instruction.
The student body is predominantly white, with smaller Asian, Black, Hispanic, and multiracial populations represented. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, an indicator of economic diversity within the school. Data on students with individual education plans and English learners was not available in the source materials.
Scioto Darby sits within Hilliard City Schools, a district serving a sprawling suburban footprint that includes the city of Hilliard, parts of Columbus and Dublin, and former Brown and Norwich Township land. The district landscape is shifting. In November 2024, voters approved a combined operating levy and bond issue for the first time in roughly fifteen years, a major funding win that will reshape school facilities over coming years. Phase 1 of the master facilities plan will replace three elementary buildings, including potential changes to building assignments as construction proceeds. The district has also committed to redistricting student boundaries in 2025 to address growth-driven enrollment imbalances; this process could affect which school families are assigned to, so families considering a move into the area may want to confirm current and projected boundaries with the district directly.
Hilliard itself is one of central Ohio's fastest-growing communities, with new mixed-use development along Interstate 270 and continued single-family subdivision building on the west side. The housing market reflects that growth: home values in the area have appreciated and rents have risen, though they remain close to state and national benchmarks. The property tax increase from the newly approved levy will add a lasting cost to homeowner tax bills.
The school's location on Scioto Darby Road places it in the suburban, auto-oriented part of the city, away from the walkable historic downtown core of Old Hilliard. Families in this area tend toward car-dependent daily patterns, though the Heritage Rail Trail, a multi-use path beginning in Old Hilliard, offers an off-street recreation option.
See more original research from School Decision →