Original Research by School Decision on Evergreen High School
Evergreen High School is a rural high school serving grades nine through twelve in Metamora, a small village in northwest Ohio where most residents own their homes and life is car-dependent. The school sits on a consolidated campus on County Road 6 alongside the elementary and middle schools, outside the village proper.
The school enrolls roughly the size typical for a rural high school, with a student body that is predominantly white, a modest share of Hispanic students, and very few students from other racial or ethnic backgrounds. Just under a third of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, placing the school in a mixed-income setting. Data on special education and English learner enrollment were not available.
On state testing, Evergreen shows strength in reading and science proficiency. Social studies proficiency is notably high. Math proficiency, while solid, lags slightly behind the other subjects. The school has reported results only for the current school year, so multi-year trend data was not available to assess whether performance has been stable, improving, or declining.
The school's graduation rate was not provided in the available data; a parent may want to request this directly from the school or district to understand college and career readiness outcomes. Similarly, chronic absenteeism and other school-environment measures such as discipline, course breadth, or staffing were not found in the public record.
Metamora itself is a genuinely small place. The village is essentially flat in population, with a very modest annual decline. Residents work primarily in manufacturing, health care, and retail, with many commuting to the Toledo metro area. Housing is affordable relative to state and national benchmarks, and home values have moved slightly downward in the past year. The local economy centers on the school district itself and a handful of civic anchors: the community library, a volunteer food bank, and the Metamora State Bank. There is no public transit; a car is essential.
The school district has renewed its income tax levy twice in recent years, most recently in November 2023. This is the district's primary local revenue stream beyond state funding, and voters have sustained it even as it drew mixed support in a 2022 referendum. For families considering the district, this signals stable funding but also an ongoing local conversation about school finances worth understanding before settling in the area.
Within the Evergreen Local district, elementary enrollment has grown modestly over five school years, suggesting household growth in the attendance area outward from the village, even as Metamora itself has not expanded. The village is updating its comprehensive plan in 2026 and publicly frames its approach as thoughtful growth that preserves small-town character.
Evergreen High School is a good fit for families seeking rural, small-town schooling with manageable class sizes and solid foundational academics. The reading, science, and social studies results suggest capable instruction. Math proficiency sits lower, so a parent should ask how the school supports students who find the subject challenging. For families whose work or lifestyle centers on the Toledo region or who prefer a rural, quiet setting with lower housing costs and a tight-knit peer environment, the school offers a clear alternative to suburban or urban schools. For families who prize program diversity, specialized pathways, or extensive extracurricular offerings, the school's size and rural location mean fewer options than a larger district would provide.
See more original research from School Decision →