The top reported proficiency rate is 61% in English language arts. The lowest is 23% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Cardinal High School
Cardinal High School is a small, rural public high school in Middlefield, Ohio, serving students from a three-district consolidation in what was formerly the Cardinal Local district. The school sits in a manufacturing and agricultural community known for its large Amish population, where horse-drawn buggies and farm life coexist with industrial plants and family businesses. For a family moving to or staying in the area, this school reflects a working-class, tight-knit rural setting with modest academic performance overall, meaningful variation across subjects, and a recent consolidation that has reshaped how the district operates.
The school's enrollment is small, with roughly two hundred forty students spread across grades nine through twelve, distributed fairly evenly by grade. About a third of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is overwhelmingly white, reflecting the Amish and non-Amish European ethnic composition of the broader Middlefield area.
Academic performance is uneven. Students perform well in language arts and social studies, where proficiency is above the statewide threshold. Science proficiency is solid and respectable. Mathematics proficiency, however, is notably low—only about a quarter of students tested met state proficiency in math across grades three and eight. When the school reports its overall proficiency index across all tested subjects and grades, Cardinal ranks in the bottom quartile among the six districts in Geauga County, the comparison set for this school. A parent may want to look into what the school is doing to address the math gap and whether there are supplemental or intervention resources available for students who struggle in that area.
State testing data appear to reflect recent years and were conducted with high participation rates, so the numbers are reliable representations of current performance. The school does not yet report a graduation rate in the available data, which may reflect recent changes in the district's structure or data collection, not a problem with the school. No information is available on the share of students with individualized education plans or English learners, nor on course offerings, AP programs, career pathways, or staffing details.
The district itself has undergone a significant restructuring. An elementary building, A.J. Jordak, was closed in summer 2024, consolidating all students into two facilities: an elementary and middle school on Almeda Drive and the junior/senior high on Thompson Avenue. This restructuring happened amid declining enrollment and was accompanied by staff reductions through attrition. The closure is tangible and lasting; it means every student in the district now attends one of two buildings instead of three. The sale of the Jordak property to a private buyer generated funds that the district is using to upgrade facilities at the remaining schools—new HVAC, a new roof for the high school, and a new parking lot. These upgrades benefit students currently enrolled, but the consolidation and the enrollment decline that prompted it are realities of the district's current operating environment.
Middlefield itself is a compact village with identifiable downtown retail and strong manufacturing roots. Home values are moderate for the region, and the area has experienced steady but controlled growth through planned subdivisions. The community is economically anchored by kitchen cabinet manufacturing, plastics, and industrial production, alongside Amish-run businesses and retail. A remodeled library branch and a multi-use bike path provide civic anchors, and the setting is genuinely rural outside the village center, with country roads and open land. Public transit is available through demand-response county service.
For a family, Cardinal High School offers the experience of a small-town rural school in a working-class community with real historic roots. The current academic profile—strong humanities, weak mathematics—and the district's recent consolidation are factors to weigh carefully when deciding whether this school is a good fit.
See more original research from School Decision →