The top reported proficiency rate is 90% in Science. The lowest is 73% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Nagel Middle School
Nagel Middle School serves grades seven and eight in Cincinnati's eastern suburbs as a regular public school within Forest Hills Local School District. The school sits in a growing area where housing values have been rising, with families in the district shoulder meaningful property tax commitments after a levy passed in 2023 to stabilize operations and fund facility improvements.
The school's academic profile is a strength. Across the most recent state testing in math, English language arts, and science, Nagel shows consistent proficiency that places it above the midpoint among the district comparisons in Hamilton County. In science, the school's performance is particularly strong. In English language arts, proficiency is also solid. Math shows somewhat lower proficiency than the other two subjects but remains respectable. The school tested nearly full participation rates across all three subjects, meaning the results reflect most of the student body. Trend data for multiple years was not available, so a parent cannot assess whether performance is improving or holding steady, but the current snapshot points to a school where the majority of students are meeting or exceeding state standards.
The enrollment runs to about one thousand students, split evenly between seventh and eighth grade. The student body is predominantly white, with smaller shares of students from Asian, multiracial, Hispanic, and Black backgrounds. A modest share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, suggesting the school draws from a relatively stable economic zone compared to some urban Cincinnati schools. Data on students with IEPs or English learners was not reported, so the full picture of support services remains unclear; a parent may want to ask the school directly about special education and language learner programs and their staffing.
The school sits on Nagel Road in the 45255 zip code, placing it in an area where single-family homes and suburban development dominate. The broader Cincinnati region is experiencing moderate growth and apartment construction activity, particularly downtown and in faster-growing suburbs. The Forest Hills area itself is largely built out but well-established, with housing costs that reflect the district's relatively strong schools and suburban location. Mortgage affordability and rent-to-income ratios in the area are reasonable relative to national benchmarks, though property taxes are a cost factor families should factor in given the recent levy.
Forest Hills Local itself has been through a cultural transition in recent years, most visibly with Anderson High School's mascot change from Redskins to Raptors, which the community undertook through a deliberate process. The district also faced budget pressures before voters approved the 2023 levy. These changes mean the district has been navigating both resource constraints and identity questions, though the levy passage suggests community commitment to the schools.
Data on teacher staffing, discipline policies, course offerings at the middle school level, attendance, and whether the school offers any specialized programs or pathways was not available. A parent considering Nagel would benefit from reaching out to the school about what electives and exploratory courses are offered in seventh and eighth grade, what the school's approach to student support and discipline looks like, and what resources it dedicates to students who arrive below grade level or need acceleration. The strong proficiency numbers suggest the school has functional systems in place, but the specifics of how the school meets individual student needs require a conversation with the school itself.
See more original research from School Decision →