The top reported proficiency rate is 95% in Social studies. The lowest is 78% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Hilltop Elementary School
Hilltop Elementary serves kindergarten through fourth grade in Canfield, a small suburban city in Mahoning County southwest of Youngstown. The school enrolls about a typical size for an elementary school at this grade band, drawn from Canfield, Canfield Township, and parts of adjacent townships. About a fifth of the enrollment qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is predominantly white, with small numbers of Asian, Hispanic, and multiracial students; counts of students with individualized education plans or English learner status were not available in the data.
On state testing, Hilltop's performance in math is substantially above the midpoint for districts in Mahoning County, placing the school in the top quartile of county elementary and middle schools on overall proficiency. The school's math proficiency rate is notably strong. English language arts proficiency runs lower, though still above the county median. A single social studies assessment from fourth grade in a prior year showed very high proficiency. Current trend data span only one year, so multi-year patterns cannot be seen.
The school operates within Canfield Local, a district that has faced three consecutive failed bond levies since 2022, each intended to replace the century-old middle school and renovate elementary buildings including Hilltop. The aging facility issue remains unresolved and is an active concern for families in the district; future levy attempts and possible tax increases are a live question. That said, the district has moved meaningfully on academic programming. Both Hilltop and the other elementary school were named Governor's Science of Reading Champion Award schools in 2026, meaning they have aligned their literacy instruction with the science of reading. The district also substantially expanded its course offerings, adding new pathways in STEM, career and technical areas, and advanced academics for students in middle and high school. Parents weighing Hilltop should understand it as part of this changing landscape: a school with above-average elementary math performance and a literacy program now anchored in current reading science, set against a district contending with aging buildings and the outcome of deferred capital investment.
Housing values in the Canfield area, where the school sits, are moderately below the state benchmark, making the area somewhat more affordable than Ohio as a whole. The community itself has a defined downtown around a historic village green but is predominantly suburban and car-oriented, with development spread across subdivisions. The Canfield Fairgrounds is the major civic landmark. The city continues to add residential development and some retail and lifestyle amenities, though residents commute to nearby towns for major medical services and some employment.
No data on chronic absenteeism, discipline, staffing, or attendance were provided. The school's website was not linked in the available records.
See more original research from School Decision →