The top reported proficiency rate is 73% in English language arts. The lowest is 40% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Highland Elementary School
Highland Elementary School serves pre-kindergarten through sixth grade in Marengo, a very small rural village in southern Morrow County. The school sits on a campus setting along Township Road 16, removed from any town center and set amid farmland about an hour north of Columbus. The student body is predominantly white and drawn from a handful of nearby communities including Marengo, Sparta, and Chesterville.
The school's academic profile shows solidly above-average performance in reading and math for the county. In the most recent state testing, students in grades three through six scored proficient or above in English Language Arts at a higher rate than in math, and both subjects outpaced the county median for overall proficiency across tested subjects. Science proficiency was lower, though still within the range of other district schools. These results reflect a school where the majority of tested students meet state standards, with particular strength in literacy. The school maintains very high test participation rates, indicating a consistent approach to assessment and minimal opt-out.
The enrollment sits at roughly a thousand students across all grades, making this an appropriately sized elementary school for its rural setting. About one-third of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a modest figure that reflects the working and middle-class character of the families served. The student population is racially homogeneous, with the vast majority white, reflecting both the broader regional demographics and patterns of settlement in rural central Ohio.
The school is part of Highland Local School District, which has undergone several changes relevant to families considering the area. The district completed a preschool expansion with state-certified instruction and opened a half-day program Monday through Thursday. Morrow County undertook a property reappraisal beginning in 2024 that increased property-tax-driven revenue for the district, a shift that affects homeowners' tax bills going forward. The district has also begun receiving revenue from new tax increment financing agreements, signaling commercial development in the district footprint and a slightly more diversified revenue base than property tax alone.
Marengo itself is characterized by rural residential growth. Newer single-family homes on acreage have been added in recent years, and median property values have risen modestly, reflecting the appeal of rural living with reasonable proximity to employment centers. The Dollar Tree Distribution Center just outside the village limits is the largest local employer besides the school district itself, offering warehouse and logistics work on multiple shifts. Car dependence is near-total; no fixed-route public transit serves the area, and residents own multiple vehicles per household. The Heart of Ohio Trail nearby provides a regional recreation spine for cycling and walking outside the village proper.
School-sponsored events are well-supported by parents and community members, suggesting strong family engagement with the school. This is a place where families value small-town stability, rural setting, and a straightforward K-6 elementary experience serving students before transition to the district's middle school in seventh grade.
See more original research from School Decision →