The top reported proficiency rate is 79% in Science. The lowest is 65% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on James a Garfield Middle School
James A Garfield Middle School serves seventh and eighth graders in Garrettsville, a small village in northeastern Portage County, Ohio, roughly a half hour south of Cleveland. The school is one of three on a unified campus operated by James A Garfield Local, a rural district anchored in a community of fewer than three thousand residents.
On the most recent state assessments, the school's proficiency rates cluster in a moderate range. About two-thirds of students reached proficiency in English language arts and math. Science proficiency was notably stronger, with most students demonstrating competency. Across all tested subjects, the school's overall proficiency index places it above the midpoint among the county's districts. Only one year of assessment data is available, so trend direction cannot be determined. The participation rate was complete across all subjects.
The enrollment is small, around one hundred eighty students split fairly evenly between grades seven and eight. The student body is predominantly white. The school serves a racially and ethnically homogeneous community; the data available did not include free-and-reduced-price lunch counts or English learner enrollment, so a full picture of economic need or language diversity is not present in the records provided.
Garrettsville itself is a recovery-focused village. A major downtown fire in 2019 destroyed a full city block and thirteen businesses; the last several years have brought gradual rebuilding, including new restaurants, a coffee roastery, a boardwalk, and plans for an amphitheater. The village center has walkable Main Street character with historic architecture, small independent retailers, monthly classic car gatherings, and seasonal events. The schools sit apart from downtown on a campus along State Route 88, physically separated from the civic core.
The local economy centers on retail, services, agriculture, and small manufacturing. The largest regional employer is Great Lakes Cheese, a family- and employee-owned processor headquartered nearby. The school district itself is a major local employer. Housing is affordable relative to state and national medians. The median home value in the area is modestly below the state average, and mortgage payments on a typical home would be manageable for a household earning median income for the region.
Recently, the district completed a meaningful capital project: resurfacing the all-weather track and renovating HVAC and roofing systems across buildings. The track, dedicated in spring 2025, returned home competition to campus after more than two decades, allowing athletes to train and compete on their own field rather than in parking lots or borrowed facilities. This signals ongoing investment in building condition and athletic access.
The school is a regular public middle school with no charter, magnet, or Title I designation noted in the data. State testing data was the primary academic metric available; information on specific course offerings, staffing ratios, discipline practices, attendance rates, or special-population support was not present in the materials provided. A parent may want to reach out directly to the school to discuss extracurricular breadth, special education services, or other program details beyond what state assessments capture.
See more original research from School Decision →