The top reported proficiency rate is 85% in Science. The lowest is 74% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Butler Elementary School
Butler Elementary School serves kindergarten through fifth grade in the small village of Butler, a quiet bedroom community in southeastern Richland County about a short drive from Mansfield. The school sits on College Street in the village center, making it a walkable, in-town anchor for families. It is part of Clear Fork Valley Local Schools, a small rural district that spans Butler and Bellville villages and surrounding townships.
The school enrolls a modest population for its grade band, with nearly balanced class cohorts across the grade levels. The student body is predominantly white, with a small representation of other racial and ethnic groups. About half the enrolled students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, placing the school in a mixed-income community where economic pressures are real but not uniform.
On Ohio's state assessments in 2024-25, Butler Elementary's grades 3-5 cohort showed solid performance in math and language arts, with a strong showing in science where the upper-elementary grades tested. Math proficiency ran in the low-to-mid range, language arts proficiency was slightly lower, and science proficiency was noticeably higher, suggesting relative strength in that subject for this school. The school's overall proficiency index places it at the top quartile among Richland County districts, a meaningful distinction in a county where district-level performance varies widely. All tested students participated in the state assessments.
Trend data is limited to the most recent school year, so longer-term growth patterns or year-over-year movement are not yet visible. Information on special education enrollment, English learner population, attendance, and discipline is not available. No program details such as gifted services, interventions, or enrichment offerings surfaced in the data.
The Clear Fork Valley Local district has faced enrollment decline and fiscal pressure over the past several years. In 2023, the high school eliminated roughly twenty electives and consolidated core classes after the board imposed a minimum class size of ten students. That contraction, while aimed at the secondary level, reflects district-wide enrollment loss and a projected operating deficit by the end of 2024-25. Parents considering the district should anticipate a near-term levy ballot measure and ongoing pressure on program breadth and staffing. The 2024-25 Ohio School Report Card showed the district at an overall three-star rating, with Butler Elementary rated at three stars and the secondary schools rated lower, a pattern that speaks to relative elementary strength across the district.
Butler's population has declined modestly since 2020 and shows no signs of reversal; the housing market is stable and affordable relative to state and national benchmarks, with home values and rents both moderate. The village itself is small, with a walkable downtown anchored by a library branch, museum, and trailhead of the paved B&O Bike Trail. Civic life is quiet and oriented toward outdoor recreation and small local businesses rather than growth or density. For families settled in Butler or drawn to its small-town character and lower cost of living, the elementary school offers a neighborhood-scale setting with solid state-test performance. Families planning to stay in the district long-term should factor in the secondary-school environment and the district's ongoing fiscal and program challenges.
See more original research from School Decision →