The top reported proficiency rate is 87% in Social studies. The lowest is 38% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Madison South Elementary School
Madison South Elementary School is a small public elementary school in Mansfield, Ohio, serving the youngest students in the Madison Local district—children in pre-kindergarten through fourth grade. The school has about five hundred students, with enrollment fairly even across grades except for slightly higher numbers in second grade. The student body is predominantly white, with smaller shares of Black, multiracial, and Hispanic students. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price meals, reflecting the economic profile of the families the school serves.
Academically, Madison South's most recent state testing results show a marked gap between math and reading. In math, measured across grades three and four, a majority of students met or exceeded state proficiency benchmarks. Reading proficiency is notably lower, with fewer than two in five students meeting the standard. These results place the school in the bottom quartile when compared to other schools in Richland County, suggesting students are not performing as strongly as peers across the county system. The school tested all students with full participation, so the results reflect the whole population. Data on social studies proficiency is available only from several years ago and showed strong performance then, but that measure is no longer routinely reported at the elementary level.
The context matters. Madison South sits in Mansfield, a mid-sized Ohio city that was once centered on heavy manufacturing and has been shifting toward services, healthcare, and education. The city is in the midst of a sustained downtown revitalization, with a major Main Street Corridor project underway and housing development picking up. Property values in the zip code are modest compared to state and national benchmarks, and the rental market is similarly affordable. This is a place where many families have economic constraints, which aligns with the high free-and-reduced-lunch rate at the school.
The district itself is navigating significant financial and structural changes that will directly touch this school and families. In November 2025, voters rejected a proposed earned income tax that would have replaced the property tax levy narrowly approved in 2023. That rejection set off a chain of decisions: the school board voted to close Mifflin Elementary at the end of the current school year and consolidate the elementary program into two buildings. Starting in fall 2026, Madison South will become Madison Primary School and will serve only pre-kindergarten through second grade, while fourth-graders move to Eastview Elementary. Third grade will move to Eastview as well. This is a substantial change to the school's mission, student body composition, and daily operations. Any family considering this school should expect this transition and understand that their child may change buildings partway through elementary. The district has also approved pay-to-participate fees for athletics and clubs, and has cut jobs and sold property to balance budgets. These are real changes that affect staffing and what families pay out of pocket.
Madison South is a neighborhood school that currently teaches the full elementary span in one building. Test results show students making progress in math but struggling more visibly in reading. The school serves a population with significant economic need. Families considering this school should be aware of the consolidation plan that will reshape it into a primary-grades building by fall 2026, and should view recent district financial pressures and cuts as part of the broader picture of what to expect.
See more original research from School Decision →