The top reported proficiency rate is 91% in Math. The lowest is 71% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Mifflin Elementary School
Mifflin Elementary School serves kindergarten through fourth grade in Madison Local, a small district in Mansfield, Ohio. The school enrolls a modestly sized student body drawn largely from the immediate surrounding residential area, with most students identifying as white and a substantial share qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic conditions in this neighborhood.
Academically, Mifflin shows particular strength in math. Recent state test results place the school in the top quartile among elementary schools in Richland County on overall proficiency. In math, students performed well, and reading proficiency also came in solid, though a few percentage points lower than math. Participation in state testing is strong. The school has no special education or English learner proficiency data reported in the state records, which may reflect the composition of its enrollment or may point to incomplete data capture; a parent could check directly with the building on how these students are served.
The school sits within Madison Local, which is navigating significant strain. In November 2023, voters narrowly approved the district's first new operating levy in several years by just over thirty votes, averting threatened closures. That levy will keep the school operating in the near term, but the district's finances remain tight. In November 2025 and May 2026, voters rejected proposals to shift the district's funding from property tax to earned income tax. In response, the board voted in November 2025 to consolidate the district's three elementary buildings into two, effective fall 2026. Mifflin Elementary will close at the end of the 2025-2026 school year. Students in grades 3 and 4 will move to Eastview Elementary (renamed Madison Intermediate School), and younger grades will attend Madison South (renamed Madison Primary School).
This consolidation is a major change for families with young children in the district. Mifflin will not exist as a school beyond this academic year. For any family considering the area or currently enrolled, this closure is the defining fact: where elementary-age children will attend school is shifting, and the district is implementing additional cost pressures, including reinstatement of pay-to-participate fees for athletics and clubs, alongside ongoing staffing reductions.
Mansfield itself, where the school is located, is a mid-sized Ohio city and county seat with an older manufacturing base that has diversified into services, healthcare, and education. Major employers include OhioHealth, Gorman-Rupp, and the school district itself. The city is in the midst of a downtown revitalization effort, including a Main Street Corridor Improvement Project underway through mid-2026, and is positioning to capture spillover from Intel's large semiconductor facility an hour away in Licking County. Housing values in the zip code are below state and national benchmarks, reflecting local economic conditions and the city's blue-collar heritage. The community has a clearly defined historic downtown anchored by Central Park, the Carrousel District, and the Renaissance Theatre, though car dependence is high outside the downtown core.
A parent considering Mifflin should understand that strong academic performance, particularly in math, is paired with the certainty that the building itself closes this June. The school's closure is not a reflection of its quality but rather a district-level consolidation driven by ongoing financial constraints. For families already enrolled or considering the area, the question is not whether Mifflin is a good school but whether the consolidation timeline and the receiving schools (Eastview for grades 3-4, Madison South for younger grades) fit the family's situation and preferences.
See more original research from School Decision →