The top reported proficiency rate is 91% in Social studies. The lowest is 55% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Carlisle Intermediate Elementary School
Carlisle Intermediate Elementary School serves fourth through sixth graders in Carlisle, a small residential city in southwestern Ohio nestled between Dayton and Cincinnati. The school draws its student body primarily from the surrounding suburban-to-small-town residential neighborhoods, where detached single-family homes and owner-occupied housing dominate. The school sits on Jamaica Road in a campus setting rather than in the city's modest downtown corridor.
The school enrolls a small number of students drawn from Carlisle's predominantly white population. A meaningful share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and racial diversity is minimal. Data on students with disabilities and English learners was not available.
On Ohio's most recent state tests, the school's English language arts results are its relative strength, with about two-thirds of students meeting proficiency. Reading comprehension and written expression appear to be the school's more solid areas. Science proficiency sits in the mid-range. Mathematics proficiency is the softest point; about half the students tested at proficient or above, which reflects a common challenge in the intermediate grades and one parents may want to explore further with the school—whether there are targeted supports in place, what math curriculum looks like, and how the school approaches students who struggle with computational thinking or algebra-readiness work. All three areas show full or near-full test participation, so the results reflect the full cohort rather than a subset.
The one comparison available places Carlisle Intermediate below the midpoint among the school districts in Warren County on an overall proficiency index. Graduation rate data do not apply since this is an elementary school. No chronic absenteeism data were available.
The school's home district, Carlisle Local Schools, faced a close and contentious November 2025 ballot fight when residents attempted to repeal the district's earned income tax, which funds roughly half of the operating budget and covers staffing, transportation, programs, and support services. The repeal narrowly failed, preserving revenue stability. The district also passed a five-year operating levy in May 2023 without raising taxes, signaling some local voter commitment, though the income-tax battle shows underlying fiscal tension that families considering a move to the area should factor into their assessment of the district's long-term footing. Beginning in 2026-2027, the district is adding a Miami Valley Career Technology Center satellite program at the high school, expanding career pathways without requiring students to leave the building.
Carlisle itself is in active growth. Housing values sit modestly below state benchmarks, and median rents are in the low range, making the area relatively affordable for families. The city markets itself as a ten-minute drive from Interstate 75 and is positioned between two metropolitan labor markets, which has drawn recent commercial development and new residential construction. The community is car-dependent with no fixed-route public transit; civic life centers on Central Avenue rather than a traditional walkable downtown. Parks and recreational amenities exist, though there is no dedicated public library branch within the city itself. Schools operate as separate campuses in residential areas.
For families considering this school, the picture is of a small, community-oriented elementary program in an affordably-priced, growing suburban town with a stable but fiscally contested school district. The learning environment reflects the demographic makeup of a predominantly white, modestly affluent suburb with pockets of economic need. The school's mathematics performance warrants conversation with administrators about curriculum, intervention practices, and what the roadmap looks like as students progress toward middle and high school expectations.
See more original research from School Decision →