The top reported proficiency rate is 57% in Math. The lowest is 44% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Chestnut Elementary School
Chestnut Elementary School is a regular public elementary school serving kindergarten through fifth grade in Painesville, a mixed-use county seat along the Grand River about thirty miles northeast of Cleveland. The school enrolls students across six grade bands, with a student body that is predominantly Hispanic, followed by White, African-American, and multiracial students. Specific counts for free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility and English learner status were not available.
On Ohio's State Tests in the most recent year, Chestnut's overall performance sits in the bottom quartile relative to other districts in Lake County. In math, a narrow majority of students tested at proficiency. English language arts shows lower attainment, with fewer than half of tested students meeting proficiency. Science performance falls between those two. State testing data does not extend below third grade, so results reflect only grades three through five.
These numbers reflect where the school currently stands. A parent weighing Chestnut should know that the Painesville City Local School District, the school's parent district, is navigating significant financial strain. Voters rejected a tax increase in May 2026, and the district has since locked in substantial operational cuts, including elimination of curriculum coordinator positions that had provided instructional coaching and professional development support to teachers. The district projects a negative fund balance by 2029 without additional revenue, with warnings of possible school closures, larger class sizes, reduced course offerings, and deferred building maintenance. These cuts are already in effect and will shape what classroom support and resource availability look like going forward.
The district is also implementing a district-wide shift to standards-based grading tied to Ohio's Learning Standards, with policies requiring acceptance of late work without grade penalty. This changes how report cards and assignments work and reflects a pedagogical approach centered on grade-level mastery rather than traditional letter grades.
Painesville itself is in a phase of downtown revitalization after decades of mid-20th-century decline. Recent housing development, including new construction near the historic downtown and a major residential project called Highland Park, signals renewed investment. Median home values in the zip code are modest relative to the state benchmark. The city has a strong manufacturing sector, with notable employers including Avery Dennison, Mar-Bal, Lubrizol, and AeroControlex alongside government and public education. Downtown is anchored by the historic Painesville Square with local shops and cafes, though the city overall rates as minimally walkable outside the downtown core. Lake Erie College adds an education presence, and Headlands Beach State Park, Ohio's largest beach, lies three miles north.
For a family considering Chestnut, the school offers a neighborhood elementary option in a city undergoing gradual demographic and economic transition. The current academic performance and the district's fiscal constraints are material facts that a parent may want to discuss directly with school leadership to understand how staffing cuts are affecting classroom practice and what supports remain in place for students.
See more original research from School Decision →