The top reported proficiency rate is 62% in Social studies. The lowest is 30% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Elm Street Elementary School
Elm Street Elementary School is a public school serving kindergarten through fifth grade in Painesville, a county-seat city in Lake County that sits along the Grand River, about a half-hour from Cleveland. The school enrolls a small-to-moderate population, with a student body that is roughly majority Hispanic, with substantial African American and biracial representation, and smaller shares of White and other students.
The school's recent state test results show a mixed picture across subjects. In math, proficiency sits at a level below the state median; in reading and language arts, proficiency is notably lower; and in science, proficiency stands at a similar midrange level. On the most recent available data, proficiency across tested grades hovers in the bottom tier relative to other elementary schools in Lake County. A parent may want to look into what support the school is offering in reading in particular, given that gap.
State testing data for the school's earlier grades (K-2) is not available because those grades are not tested under Ohio's assessment system. The school does have testing results from its tested grades (3-5), and all students tested participated fully in assessments.
Elm Street is part of the Painesville City Local School District, which sits in a moment of significant constraint. In May 2026, voters defeated a ballot measure seeking new income-tax revenue. The district has since locked in over $9 million in budget cuts, including elimination of positions and shortened work calendars for staff. More directly relevant to families: the district has eliminated three curriculum coordinator positions, reassigning those staff to teaching roles. That means less in-house capacity for professional development, instructional coaching, and day-to-day support for classroom teachers. This is a structural change that can affect how well teachers are resourced to teach.
The district is also moving to a fully standards-based grading and reporting system. Under the new approach, late work is accepted without grade penalty, and all students (including those with IEPs and English learners) are graded against grade-level expectations from Ohio's Learning Standards. This represents a pedagogical shift that will show up directly on your child's report card and how assignments are weighted.
The housing market in the Painesville zip code shows modest prices relative to state and national benchmarks, with home values in the mid-range and rents stable. The city itself is experiencing renewal, with new housing development and public investment in downtown parks and amenities. Painesville is known for its historic town square and a diverse, walkable core, though the city overall has limited walkability outside downtown.
For families considering Elm Street, the key context is the school's current academic performance, the district's operational pressures in the near term, and the pedagogical changes underway. The school itself operates as a standard public elementary, and the neighborhood it serves reflects Painesville's demographic makeup.
See more original research from School Decision →