The top reported proficiency rate is 47% in Math. The lowest is 35% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Maple Elementary School
Maple Elementary School is one of three elementary buildings in Painesville City Local and serves students from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in this diverse, manufacturing-anchored county seat about thirty miles northeast of Cleveland. The school enrolls a small-to-mid-sized student body with a notably diverse demographic mix: roughly half the students identify as Hispanic, and about one in seven as Black, with the remainder split among White and multiracial students. Asian students represent a small portion of the school. The school does not report free-or-reduced-price lunch counts or English learner rates, so a parent cannot see from public data how many students face economic hardship or how many are learning English as an additional language, though the city's demographics and bilingual character suggest these populations are likely present.
On state assessments administered in grades 3-5, Maple's proficiency rates fall noticeably below the county median across tested subjects. In mathematics, roughly half of tested students scored proficient or above. In English language arts, the rate drops to about one in three. Science proficiency, measured in a smaller cohort, sits at a similar level. The school participates fully in state testing, so these results reflect the student body being assessed at expected rates. Trend data spanning more than one year is not available, so it is unclear whether these results represent a stable pattern or a recent shift. Among the thirteen school districts in Lake County, Maple's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile of county schools.
The broader Painesville City Local district is navigating significant operational strain. Voters rejected the district's May 2026 bid for a continuing earned-income tax, a defeat that has triggered a cascade of budget cuts: more than a significant dollar amount in reductions, elimination of classroom teaching positions, shortened work calendars for staff, and warning of potential school closures and larger class sizes. The district has also eliminated three non-teaching curriculum coordinator positions, reassigning those staff to teaching roles. This means reduced in-house capacity for professional development and instructional coaching across the school system at the moment Maple is serving a diverse student body whose academic proficiency suggests instructional support is needed.
The district has adopted a standards-based grading system tied to Ohio's Learning Standards, a pedagogy shift that changes how assignments and report cards work. Students are graded against grade-level expectations regardless of an IEP, disability, or English proficiency status unless their IEP specifies otherwise, and the district requires accepting late work without grade penalty because lateness is not part of the state standards.
Painesville itself is a mixed-use county seat with a historic downtown anchored by a red-brick square, a strong manufacturing base, and a long history as a bilingual community where Spanish is spoken at home at higher rates than anywhere else in Ohio. The city is experiencing housing growth, with new residential development underway and median home values in the affordable range relative to state benchmarks. However, the school funding landscape and curriculum staffing cuts directly ahead represent material constraints on classroom-level instruction and support at this school and across the district.
See more original research from School Decision →