The top reported proficiency rate is 74% in Science. The lowest is 30% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on James Buchanan El Sch
James Buchanan Elementary serves kindergarten through fifth grade in Bethlehem, a mid-sized Lehigh Valley city with a split character: a walkable historic north-side downtown anchored by Moravian buildings and a denser, college-inflected south side around Lehigh University. The school sits in a diverse, mixed-income neighborhood, and its enrollment and free-lunch numbers reflect that reality. Roughly two-thirds of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is split between Hispanic students and white students, each making up a substantial share, with smaller populations of Black and Asian students.
Academically, the school's recent state test results show a bifurcated picture. In math and English language arts, proficiency on the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment sits at around one-third of tested students in the most recent year. This is below the midpoint of proficiency rates for schools across Lehigh County. Science proficiency, measured most recently in the prior year, stands notably higher, at roughly three-quarters of students tested meeting or exceeding the standard. The gap between strong science performance and lower literacy and numeracy proficiency is worth noting and asking the school about directly, as it may reflect differences in instructional focus or testing conditions across subjects.
The district itself has been in flux. Bethlehem Area School District launched a multi-year initiative in 2021 to embed research-backed reading and writing practices across all grades and subject areas, building on earlier gains in early literacy. That effort extends beyond James Buchanan and touches the whole system, which means the school is part of a district-wide shift toward structured literacy teaching. At the same time, the district drew public scrutiny in early 2023 when the state auditor found it had used accounting maneuvers to raise property taxes, and that criticism may have lingering effects on how families perceive district fiscal management.
For families considering James Buchanan, the Bethlehem community is in active growth. Mixed-use redevelopments, new apartment buildings, and affordable housing projects are reshaping both the city and surrounding Bethlehem Township, signaling demographic and economic movement. Housing values are moderate for the region and rents are stable. Transit is available through LANTA, the third-largest public transit agency in Pennsylvania, and the city is layered with walking trails and downtown pedestrian life.
A parent investigating this school would want to dig deeper into why math and reading scores sit where they do, whether the district's reading initiative is gaining ground at the elementary level, and what specific instructional approaches James Buchanan uses to support students who are not yet proficient. State test data does not capture all forms of learning, and science results suggest different dynamics may be at work in different areas of the curriculum. A visit or conversation with the principal would help clarify the school's priorities and what supports exist for students working below grade level.
See more original research from School Decision →