The top reported proficiency rate is 71% in Science. The lowest is 30% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on William Penn El Sch
William Penn Elementary serves kindergarten through fifth grade in Bethlehem, a mid-sized city in the Lehigh Valley that blends colonial history with a contemporary arts and entertainment scene. The school sits in a neighborhood anchored by a diverse, working-class student body: a substantial share qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the enrollment is roughly evenly split between Hispanic and white students, with Black students making up a smaller but present share. This composition reflects South Bethlehem's character as a densely urban, mixed-income neighborhood.
The school's academic performance shows uneven results. In science, students performed strongly on the state assessment. In mathematics and English language arts, proficiency rates were low, with roughly three in ten students meeting state benchmarks in each subject. Among county districts in Northampton County, William Penn's overall proficiency index places it below the midpoint, suggesting the school is working with students who face more academic headwinds than peers at higher-performing schools nearby.
The Bethlehem Area School District, to which William Penn belongs, has made a sustained commitment to reading instruction that began in the early grades and is now extending into upper elementary and beyond. The district partnered with Keys to Literacy to embed research-backed practices for comprehension, vocabulary, and writing across all subject areas and grade levels. That initiative shows some track record: kindergarten reading benchmarks improved notably in the years after the training rolled out. William Penn families should understand this as an ongoing, district-wide shift in how reading and writing are taught, not a program confined to individual schools.
The district has faced scrutiny around property tax practices. A state audit in early 2023 criticized the board's use of accounting moves to justify tax increases and recommended the district stop applying for referendum exceptions. That said, the district's fund balance remained in a healthy range throughout the period in question. For families considering William Penn, this is background context on district governance rather than an immediate school-level concern.
Housing in the Bethlehem zip code is modestly priced relative to state and national benchmarks, and rents have risen slowly. The city itself is in an active growth phase, with mixed-use redevelopments, apartment projects, and a new cultural arts center underway downtown. Bethlehem's walkable South Side is anchored by Lehigh University and lined with restaurants, shops, and murals; public transit connects the city to Allentown and beyond.
William Penn is a small elementary school in a neighborhood and district where a teaching focus on literacy and foundational skills has become a priority. Parents considering enrollment will see a school serving a majority economically disadvantaged student population with low proficiency rates in core academics but a district making explicit, sustained efforts to strengthen how reading and writing are taught across grade levels.
See more original research from School Decision →