The top reported proficiency rate is 39% in Science. The lowest is 19% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Donegan El Sch
Donegan Elementary is a small school serving grades pre-K through five in south Bethlehem, with an enrollment drawn almost entirely from the surrounding neighborhood. The student body is predominantly Hispanic, with a substantial portion of Black students and a smaller Asian population; white students make up a minority. An overwhelming majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic profile of the area.
On state assessments, Donegan's performance sits below the midpoint compared to other elementary schools across Northampton County. In the most recent testing, proficiency in English language arts and math both sat in the low range, while science proficiency from the prior year was notably stronger, suggesting uneven academic performance across subjects. The school tests a moderate number of students in the upper elementary grades where state assessments are administered.
The broader Bethlehem Area School District, Donegan's parent district, has been implementing a sustained, research-backed literacy initiative since 2021 that extends across all grades and content areas. The district partnered with Keys to Literacy to build teacher capacity in comprehension, vocabulary, and writing instruction. For early grades, this work showed measurable gains in kindergarten reading benchmarks over time. That instructional focus has potential relevance for Donegan families, though the school's own test results have not yet reflected major shifts in proficiency.
The district itself has faced scrutiny. A state audit in January 2023 criticized Bethlehem Area's tax and budgeting practices, finding the district used accounting moves and referendum exceptions to justify property tax increases in ways the auditor deemed unnecessary. For the 2024-25 school year, the state placed seven BASD schools on improvement lists due to performance gaps, though Donegan was not named among them. Two elementary schools in the district, Freemansburg and Marvine, were flagged for targeted improvement, while Broughal Middle School received the more serious comprehensive improvement designation.
Bethlehem itself is a mid-sized Lehigh Valley city with walkable downtowns on both the north and south sides, a working arts and cultural scene, and active development. The neighborhood around Donegan, in south Bethlehem, is densely urban with rowhouses and strong pedestrian networks. Housing values in the zip code are moderate compared to state and national benchmarks, and rental costs are accessible. Major employers include St. Luke's University Health Network, Lehigh University, the school district itself, and various manufacturers and retail operations. The area is experiencing visible growth with mixed-use redevelopment, affordable housing projects in planning stages, and new retail and cultural anchors like the ArtsQuest Cultural Arts Center coming online.
Donegan's small size means tight classroom groups and a neighborhood school feel. Families should be aware that state testing data shows the school's academic performance trails peers in the county, and may want to discuss with the school directly how it is addressing literacy instruction and the particular academic needs of its student population.
See more original research from School Decision →