The top reported proficiency rate is 79% in Science. The lowest is 47% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on School Street El Sch
School Street Elementary serves grades three through five in Bradford, a small city in McKean County that has undergone long-term population decline from its oil-boom peak. The school educates a student body of roughly five hundred, nearly all white and virtually all from low-income households qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. Test results present a mixed picture. In science, proficiency runs substantially higher, placing the school in the top quartile when compared to other districts in McKean County. In English language arts and math, proficiency stands closer to the county median, with fewer than half of tested students reaching proficiency in each subject. The school's overall proficiency index across tested subjects places it above the county median, a position that reflects strength in science offsetting weaker performance in reading and computation.
The immediate context shapes enrollment and family planning significantly. The Bradford Area School District proposed a property tax increase for the coming year, its first in several years, and has publicly considered closing School Street Elementary as part of cost-saving measures. For families living in Bradford, this potential consolidation carries real weight: the school may not exist as currently configured, and which building serves their child remains uncertain. Housing values in the Bradford zip code are modest relative to state and national benchmarks, and the rental market is correspondingly tight, so a family's school choice touches directly on where they can live.
The district also adopted a new restrictive cell phone policy taking effect in the 2025-26 school year, intended to improve academic focus and face-to-face interaction. This represents a deliberate pedagogical shift across all district schools that parents considering enrollment should know about, since classroom dynamics and discipline approach matter to many families.
Science appears to be a relative strength at School Street Elementary, and parents weighing the school should understand that the gap between its science results and its literacy and math results is real and substantial. Whether that gap reflects better instruction in science, a different student cohort taking that assessment, or other factors is not clear from the data; the school's website was not available to provide additional detail. A parent interested in this school may want to ask the district directly about the science performance and what instruction looks like in reading and math, given the lower proficiency rates in those areas.
See more original research from School Decision →