The top reported proficiency rate is 64% in Science. The lowest is 26% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Brentwood Ms
Brentwood Middle School serves grades six through eight in the Brentwood Borough School District, a small district south of Pittsburgh. The school sits in a community undergoing significant change, with the most visible shift being the consolidation of the district's two aging elementary schools into a single new building scheduled to open for the 2026-27 school year. This marks a substantial recapitalization of the district and carries a property-tax increase that affects all Brentwood households.
The school enrolls students drawn almost entirely from the immediate borough, a population that is predominantly white and faces economic pressure. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price meals. The student body includes a small number of Asian, Black, and Hispanic students alongside white and multiracial peers. Data on special education enrollment and English learners was not available.
Academic performance shows a divided picture. In English language arts, proficiency is near the middle ground, with roughly half of tested students meeting the state standard. Mathematics proficiency is notably low, with only about a quarter of students reaching proficiency. Science performed better on the most recent available assessment, with roughly two-thirds of students proficient. When considered together, these results place the school's overall proficiency below the midpoint relative to districts in Allegheny County.
The school's performance reflects real constraints. A parent evaluating Brentwood should recognize that math is a significant gap. The disparity between strong science results and weak math results is noteworthy and worth understanding directly with the school, as it may point to specific program strengths or needs. State testing data for 2024-25 in science was not available; the science figure reflects 2023-24 results only. No information was provided about attendance, discipline, course offerings, staffing, or advanced programs at the middle school level.
The broader context matters for families considering the district. Brentwood is a small community with modest housing costs relative to other Pittsburgh-area neighborhoods. The ongoing elementary school construction project represents a long-term commitment to facility modernization, but it also comes with a visible tax increase that families will carry throughout the building phase. The district's demographic composition and economic profile are quite different from larger urban or affluent suburban districts, which shapes both peer environment and school culture.
For a parent, the key takeaway is straightforward: this is a neighborhood middle school in a working-class borough with mixed academic results, particularly in mathematics, set within a district making a substantial infrastructure investment. Whether Brentwood fits a family's needs depends on what they prioritize in a peer group, their comfort with the property-tax trajectory, and whether the school's apparent strength in science aligns with their child's interests and learning style.
See more original research from School Decision →