The top reported proficiency rate is 76% in Science. The lowest is 39% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Claysburg-kimmel El Sch
Claysburg-Kimmel Elementary School serves kindergarten through sixth grade in Claysburg, a small unincorporated community nestled in the Allegheny foothills of Blair County. The school draws roughly evenly across its grade bands, with the enrollment heavily concentrated in one demographic. The student body is predominantly white, with all students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch, making this a Title I-eligible school community with shared economic challenges across its families.
The school's academic performance shows a mixed picture on state assessments. In English language arts, proficiency sits below half the tested population. Mathematics proficiency is notably lower, with fewer than half of tested third through eighth graders meeting state benchmarks. Science performance, measured in the previous school year, was substantially stronger and well above the proficiency floor, suggesting the school has instructional depth in at least one core subject. Against the constellation of districts in Blair County, Claysburg-Kimmel's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile, a position that reflects both the school's own achievement and the broader county context.
The district has recently undertaken a meaningful curriculum overhaul in mathematics, partnering with intermediary education specialists to shift the pedagogy toward conceptual understanding and problem-solving. This work is still unfolding and reflects awareness of the math attainment gap. The secondary side has also experienced staffing gaps; a math teacher position was vacant, though hiring is now under discussion for the coming year. For a parent considering this school, the math curriculum redesign may signal improvement ahead, though the current numbers suggest that arithmetic and reasoning skills remain an area where the school is working to build capacity.
Beyond academics, the district has woven together several wraparound programs funded by state and federal grants. A K-6 summer program launched recently with tutoring and social-emotional content, a Buddy Club connecting mainstream students with special education peer experiences, and a Mentoring for Success initiative linking high school students to local employers. These programs suggest an effort to build student resilience and real-world awareness within the constraints of a rural, economically stretched community.
The housing market in Claysburg reflects its working-class heritage and modest growth. Home values are well below both state and national medians, and have appreciated modestly. Most residents own their homes, and the stock is predominantly older single-family properties. Property taxes have risen consistently, with the district approving increases to the maximum allowable amount for multiple budget cycles to manage payroll and health-care costs. A parent relocating here would find affordable entry-level housing but should expect ongoing tax pressure tied to the fiscal constraints of a small, aging district.
Claysburg itself is a quiet, car-dependent community with limited walkability and no public transit. Civic and school life cluster along Bedford Street, the main spine through town. Recreation is anchored by nearby Blue Knob State Park and the Blue Knob All Seasons Resort. The community retains its working-class, multi-generational character, and the school sits at the heart of daily civic life.
For families choosing an elementary school here, the draw is typically proximity, affordability, and a tight-knit community feel rather than exceptional test scores or breadth of programs. The school's current strength in science and ongoing curriculum work in math suggest staff investment in learning. The all-free-lunch enrollment signals families facing real economic pressure, and the school's peer environment will reflect that lived reality. This is a place where a small-town K-6 experience, sustained local commitment, and modest means intersect.
See more original research from School Decision →