The top reported proficiency rate is 92% in Science. The lowest is 57% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Reamstown El Sch
Reamstown Elementary School is a small, traditional public school serving kindergarten through fifth grade in a historic village setting in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. The school sits within the walkable core of Reamstown village itself, at the center of a tightly knit community of narrow-lot homes and long-established residences, though families moving to the area should know that secondary education occurs on separated campuses elsewhere in the district.
The school enrolls a student body that is majority white, with a stable overall enrollment split fairly evenly across grade levels. Close to half the student population qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating a working-class base. Data on students with individualized education plans or English learners was not available.
On state math and reading assessments administered in spring 2025, the school's proficiency rates fell below the midpoint. Math proficiency stood just over half, while English language arts proficiency was somewhat lower. Science testing data from the prior year showed much stronger results. Across tested subjects, the school ranks in the top quartile of districts in Lancaster County by overall proficiency. This mixed picture suggests strength in science instruction and reasoning, with room for growth in foundational math and literacy skills. A parent may want to ask the school directly about how reading and math are being taught, what interventions exist for students not yet proficient, and what support is available beyond the school day. The district has recently eliminated after-school tutoring programs as a budget reduction, so families relying on extra academic help should confirm what alternatives remain.
The broader context matters. The Cocalico School District, to which this school belongs, is under significant financial strain. The district has run operating deficits for six consecutive years and has raised property taxes in back-to-back years to try to close the gap. The most recent increases mean homeowners at median assessed values are paying substantially more annually. With a limited business tax base in the rural area, the burden falls heavily on residential taxpayers. The district's fund balance has shrunk considerably over the past several years. Beyond tax hikes, the district has cut expenses including staff reductions, deferred technology purchases, and the elimination of after-school tutoring. Families considering a move to the area should anticipate continued property tax pressure.
On the instructional side, the district completed a curriculum overhaul in late 2022 and now uses Curriculum Associates' iReady as its core elementary math program. This approach emphasizes problem-solving and classroom discourse rather than traditional computation practice, so students will experience a particular teaching style in math.
Reamstown village itself is growing. The surrounding East Cocalico Township has dozens of active development projects, including mixed single-family and multi-family housing subdivisions, which means school enrollment pressure and neighborhood change are likely ongoing. The village has a historic downtown streetscape with walking access to the school, but most daily destinations sit outside that core and require a car. The area's employment base centers on manufacturing, health care, and construction, with industrial parks along the township's commercial corridor. The school's location in the historic village core, combined with the district's recent curriculum framework, creates a fairly traditional, stable educational environment. The financial pressures and budget cuts the district is managing will be a practical consideration for any family enrolling here.
See more original research from School Decision →