The top reported proficiency rate is 91% in Science. The lowest is 54% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Conneaut Valley El Sch
Conneaut Valley Elementary serves kindergarten through fourth grade in Conneautville, a small rural borough in northwestern Pennsylvania along Conneaut Creek. The school is located on State Highway 18 south of the borough center, on the same campus that once housed a now-closed middle school.
The school enrolls a small population of students, nearly all of whom qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is predominantly white, with very few students of other racial or ethnic backgrounds. No data on special education enrollment or English learner population was available in the school's public reports.
On the most recent state assessment results available, the school's performance is mixed. In science, proficiency was strong at the high end. Reading and mathematics proficiency rates, measured across third and fourth grades, fell in the mid-range: just above half of students tested demonstrated proficiency in mathematics, and slightly below that threshold in English language arts. The school's overall proficiency index positions it in the top quartile among the five districts in Crawford County, though the county baseline itself is modest. Trend data was not available, so whether these results represent improvement, decline, or stability cannot be determined from the information provided.
The borough itself is contracting. Population has fallen steadily over decades, and the housing market reflects that: home values in the area are well below county and state medians, and the active for-sale inventory is sparse. Most residents own their homes outright, and a substantial share are retirees. The broader area is rural and auto-dependent; there is no public transit. Civic life centers on Stone Memorial Library on Main Street, a longstanding anchor founded in the early twentieth century.
A significant institutional change has reshaped the district since the school year that began in 2024. The Conneaut School District closed Conneaut Valley Middle School at the end of the 2023-24 school year and consolidated all middle grades into a single school at the Conneaut Lake site. In this reconfiguration, all fifth graders moved to the elementary schools. For families in the Conneautville area, this means longer bus rides to the consolidated middle school and a single shared middle-school experience serving the entire district. The vacant middle school building on the same campus remains unsold, and the district faced an unexpected property tax bill on it, an ongoing financial dispute with Crawford County.
A parent looking at this school should understand the local economy and trajectory: this is a shrinking rural borough where growth is not expected, where most families own their homes but at modest values, and where school enrollment will likely continue to decline. The elementary school itself serves a high-poverty population. Academic performance on state tests is above the county baseline but not strong in core subjects, with one notable exception in science. For families already rooted in Conneautville or the surrounding townships, the school is accessible and small; for those considering a move to the area, the broader community conditions and modest proficiency rates warrant careful consideration against available alternatives.
See more original research from School Decision →