The top reported proficiency rate is 77% in Science. The lowest is 38% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on First District El Sch
First District Elementary School serves kindergarten through sixth grade in Meadville, a small Crawford County city that sits at the intersection of a historic downtown, a college campus, and a manufacturing economy. The school is a regular public elementary serving students across that full early and middle-elementary band.
The student body is economically disadvantaged: all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The school is racially mixed, with a white plurality, a substantial multiracial population, and smaller shares of Black, Hispanic, and Asian students, reflecting both the broader county composition and some economic sorting within Meadville itself.
In terms of tested academics, the picture is uneven. Science performance on state assessment was strong, with a majority of tested students reaching proficiency. English language arts shows a lower but still moderate share of students meeting the standard. Mathematics proficiency was the lowest of the three subjects, with fewer than half of tested students demonstrating proficiency at grade level. When averaged across all tested subjects, the school's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile relative to other districts in Crawford County, though that comparison reflects the county's own modest performance levels rather than statewide strength.
Reading the state data requires context: Pennsylvania administers its regular assessment to grades three through eight, so kindergarten, first, and second grade are not tested. The proficiency measures shown here cover the third through sixth graders who took the assessment. The school tested a cohort of third through sixth graders; the number who sat for each subject was consistent, suggesting good participation.
Meadville as a place is navigating real economic transition. The city has an aging housing stock, a shrinking population, and rents that burden many local families. At the same time, there is active investment: housing rehabilitation through nonprofits, federal funding for affordable homes downtown, and state money for the historic Market House and downtown planning. Allegheny College is a steady civic anchor, and the downtown core remains walkable and anchored by local business.
The district itself faces structural budget pressure. Enrollment is declining, and the district has signaled that at least one Meadville elementary building may close as part of consolidation efforts. A head tax was reinstated in 2025 after being eliminated years earlier. Property taxes rose in the 2024-25 budget, and the district used fund balance to close a deficit, a pattern that publicly reported sources indicate has continued. Whether First District is the building under consideration for closure is not stated in available information, but the broader consolidation context means families should engage directly with the district office about any building-level changes ahead.
The school is small, with enrollment spread across seven grades. Staffing details and program offerings beyond the standard elementary curriculum were not available. A parent considering this school may want to look into current enrollment and facility plans with the district, especially given the publicly reported consolidation discussions.
See more original research from School Decision →