The top reported proficiency rate is 79% in Science. The lowest is 53% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Leib El Sch
Leib El School serves kindergarten through fifth grade in Dover, a small, steadily growing borough-and-township community in northwestern York County. The school sits in an area defined by mixed residential development, farmland, and car-dependent commercial strips rather than a walkable urban core, with Brookside Park and the Bob Hoffman YMCA as local civic anchors. Housing in the Dover area is modestly priced, and the community is on an active growth trajectory with new residential subdivisions and builder activity, though families should be aware that the district—which covers both Dover Borough and Dover Township—has been operating under structural budget pressure, with school leaders publicly weighing tax increases against potential program cuts including possible reductions to middle school athletics.
The school's enrollment is small, at under four hundred students, with a racial composition that is predominantly white, a minority Hispanic population, and very small numbers of Asian and Black students. Nearly all students come from households qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch, meaning the school serves a population where economic need is nearly universal. The school has no reported data on special education identification or English learner enrollment; a parent may want to look into these details with the school directly if either is relevant to their child.
On state testing in grades three through five, Leib El's math proficiency sits in the upper range among York County's schools—well above the county median. English language arts proficiency is lower, sitting near the county median, meaning roughly half of tested students are meeting the standard. Science proficiency, last reported for the prior school year, was strong. Overall, the school's proficiency index places it in the top quartile relative to other districts in York County, suggesting it is one of the stronger-performing elementary schools in the county on the measures tested.
The Dover Area School District has recently completed a substantial facility upgrade, opening a new high school and renovated middle school in fall 2020 with modern instructional spaces, a natatorium, and auditorium—an asset families may value for later grades. More recently, the district launched a new reading program and renewed its math curriculum across elementary grades during the 2024-2025 school year, representing a meaningful instructional change. However, the district has faced a significant structural shift: Washington Township was transferred out of the district in 2021 following a state petition process, a change still creating financial strain. Budget talks remain ongoing, and the superintendent has signaled that without additional revenue, cuts will be necessary.
Leib El itself offers a neighborhood elementary experience in a town built for families, within a district managing real fiscal constraints. A parent looking for a well-performing elementary school in a growing, modestly priced residential area, and prepared to follow district budget and curricular changes, will find solid academic results here. Those seeking to understand the full context—especially around special services, or the longer-term implications of district finances—should check directly with the school and district office.
See more original research from School Decision →