The top reported proficiency rate is 27% in Science. The lowest is 9% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Diehl Sch
Diehl School is a public elementary school in Erie, Pennsylvania serving pre-K through fifth grade, located at the Fairmont Parkway address in the 16510 ZIP code. It enrolls a school population of moderate size for its grade band, roughly evenly distributed across the grades, with particularly strong representation in fourth and fifth grade.
The school's student body reflects Erie's racial and economic profile. About two-thirds of students are Black, white, or multiracial in roughly equal proportions, with a smaller Hispanic population and an Asian population that is meaningful though not dominant. Virtually all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating that Diehl serves a population with little to no household resources for out-of-pocket school expenses. No data on special education enrollment or English learner status was available.
Academic performance at Diehl is substantially below proficiency on Pennsylvania's assessments. In math (grades 3-8 combined), a small fraction of students tested scored proficient or above. English language arts performance is even lower. Science proficiency was higher but still modest, based on a smaller tested sample. On the county comparison across Erie County's school districts, Diehl ranks in the bottom quartile for overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades.
State testing data was the only academic measure available. Graduation rate, attendance, and chronic absenteeism data do not apply to this school given its grade span of pre-K through fifth. No information on course offerings, extracurricular programs, staffing levels, or school culture was present in the available data.
Erie itself is a mid-sized lakefront city with a mixed economy of manufacturing, insurance, healthcare, and higher education. Downtown is the civic hub, anchored by Gannon University, UPMC Hamot hospital, Erie Insurance, government offices, and cultural institutions. The broader city has experienced steady population loss over recent decades, though downtown has entered a reinvestment cycle led by the nonprofit Erie Downtown Development Corporation, which is converting historic vacant buildings into mixed-use residential and commercial spaces. The Bayfront area is also undergoing mixed-use redevelopment. Manufacturing remains a significant part of the local workforce alongside service industries.
Housing in the ZIP code where Diehl sits is modestly valued relative to state and national benchmarks, and rent is comparatively affordable, reflecting Erie's lower cost of living. The unemployment rate in the region is moderate, and median household income locally is near the national average.
The Erie City School District, Diehl's parent district, has faced sustained financial pressure. The board has raised property taxes in three consecutive years to offset the expiration of pandemic relief funds and to close a state funding gap; district leadership has publicly stated that Erie ranks among Pennsylvania's ten most underfunded districts. Families considering the district should expect this tax trajectory to continue unless state funding changes materially. Additionally, in early 2026 the school board voted to study whether to reverse a consolidation from about a decade ago that combined East and Strong Vincent high schools into middle schools and left Erie High School as the city's sole comprehensive high school. Overcrowding at Erie High is cited as a driver. This signals that school configurations may shift over the next several years, which could affect which building students attend at the secondary level.
A parent evaluating Diehl would benefit from a direct conversation with the school about what specific interventions or supports are in place to address the gap between current proficiency levels and grade-level standards, and what the school's strategic priorities are for improvement.
See more original research from School Decision →