The top reported proficiency rate is 81% in Science. The lowest is 70% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Schaeffer Sch
Schaeffer School is a neighborhood elementary school in Manheim Township, serving kindergarten through fourth grade in a small suburban setting in Lancaster County. The school enrolls a mixed population: just over a quarter of students are Hispanic, roughly one in six are Asian or multiracial, just under one in fourteen are Black, and the majority are white. About two in five students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The enrollment sits at typical size for its grade span, with kindergarten through fourth scattered fairly evenly across the building.
The school's most recent state test results show solid academic performance. In math, about three in four students in grades three and four scored at proficient or above levels. English language arts proficiency ran somewhat lower, with about seven in ten students meeting that bar. Science results from the prior year showed stronger performance, with roughly four in five students proficient. Across tested subjects, Schaeffer ranks in the top quartile among the county's districts when proficiency performance is averaged together, a meaningful distinction.
Manheim Township School District itself sits in an active planning phase. The board has decided to build a brand-new elementary school rather than renovate the aging Nitrauer building, a capital commitment spanning years and affecting the K-4 experience across the district. The district has raised property taxes in recent budget years, and a substantial budget shortfall is projected for the coming cycles, suggesting taxes may continue rising. The district is also preparing for Lancaster County's 2027 property reassessment, which will reset home values countywide and likely reset tax bills as well. For families already in or considering Manheim Township homes, this financial trajectory is worth understanding.
At the high school level, Manheim Township eliminated class rank from transcripts for the graduating class of 2026 onward, a shift that affects how college admissions offices and scholarship committees evaluate the school's graduates against ranked peers from other county districts. The district is the only one in Lancaster County to make this move.
The town of Lancaster itself is a small, walkable city centered on a vibrant downtown. Central Market, the nation's oldest continuously-operating farmers' market, anchors daily commerce, while dense brick neighborhoods with tree-lined streets lie within easy walking distance of shops, galleries, theaters, and restaurants. A new Lancaster Public Library opened downtown in 2023. The housing market is seeing substantial new construction: a retirement tower is planned as the county's tallest building, and several apartment projects have recently opened or are under way, drawing younger residents and families into the city. Home values and rents in the 17601 zip code where Schaeffer sits are moderate for the region. Mortgage affordability is mixed given current interest rates, though rents run somewhat lower as a share of typical household income than mortgage costs would.
Schaeffer serves as the local neighborhood school for its area of the township. The academic results and peer composition are straightforward enough to assess from the data provided. What matters more to the family considering this school is likely the trajectory of the district's finances and facilities planning, the nature of the township and city neighborhoods around it, and whether the current K-4 model and the planned new elementary construction timeline align with their children's timeline and their own housing or relocation plans.
See more original research from School Decision →