The top reported proficiency rate is 53% in Science. The lowest is 42% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Mcguffey Ms
McGuffey MS is a public middle school serving grades six through eight in Claysville, a small borough in Washington County in the Pittsburgh metro area. The school draws students from a nine-municipality region in western Pennsylvania, not just from Claysville itself.
The student body numbers about mid-range for a middle school of its grade span, with enrollment split roughly evenly across the three grades. Just over half of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating substantial economic need in the catchment area. The student population is predominantly white, with very limited racial diversity; counts of Black, Hispanic, and Asian students are each at or near zero. The school does not report separate data on special education enrollment or English learner status, so those figures are not available.
On the most recent Pennsylvania System of School Assessment results, McGuffey MS shows proficiency rates in the upper-forties to low-fifties range across tested subjects. In English language arts, just over half of students achieved proficiency. Math proficiency sits below that, in the low-forties. Science results from the prior year showed proficiency just above fifty percent. Taken together, these place the school's overall proficiency index above the midpoint among the county's school districts, a meaningful position that reflects mixed but not weak academic ground. Parents may want to look into the school's response to the math numbers specifically and what classroom supports are in place for students not yet proficient in that subject.
The parent district, McGuffey School District, has made curriculum intentional in recent years. Beginning in 2022-23, the district adopted a new math curriculum framework across all grades, introducing Reveal Mathematics as the core resource for middle school, supplemented by personalized learning and intervention tools. That kind of system-wide program change affects daily classroom practice and represents the district's bet on its math direction. The district has also adopted a strategic framework emphasizing high expectations, student attendance, and teacher retention, priorities that were formally set in 2022 and updated in 2025.
Claysville itself is a quiet, older small town of a few thousand people, about midway between Pennsylvania's central regions and the Pittsburgh area. The borough has a compact Main Street (the historic National Road) with locally-owned businesses and a walkable downtown core, but outside that stretch it is residential and car-dependent. Population has been slowly declining over recent years, and Main Street has lost several long-standing family businesses. Community leaders completed a revitalization plan in 2022 focused on downtown investment and economic growth across the wider school district region. Marcellus Shale natural gas development in Washington County has been a significant economic force shaping the surrounding area.
Housing in the Claysville zip code is comparatively affordable for the broader region. A typical home price falls below the state average and runs around two-point-seven times median household income, making homeownership feasible for working families. Rents are also low relative to income. The neighborhood is predominantly owner-occupied, with a notably older population and strong retiree presence.
State testing data across science, math, and reading are available. Attendance and chronic absenteeism figures were not reported for this school. Special education and English learner enrollment counts were not reported. A graduation rate does not apply, as the school serves only middle grades, not high school. No information on advanced coursework, electives, arts, athletics, or other extracurricular offerings was provided.
See more original research from School Decision →