The top reported proficiency rate is 76% in Science. The lowest is 36% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Robert Reid El Sch
Robert Reid Elementary is a school serving kindergarten through fifth grade in Middletown, a small historic borough on the Susquehanna River south of Harrisburg. The school sits in a community with deep roots—Middletown is the oldest incorporated place in Dauphin County—and a modest, mixed-income character. About two-thirds of Reid's enrollment qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the student body reflects the borough's diversity: roughly a third of students are Hispanic or multiracial, with a smaller Black population and a White plurality.
The school enrolls roughly mid-sized for an elementary building in this grade range. The enrollment leans slightly toward the earlier grades, with smaller cohorts in fourth and fifth.
On state assessments, Reid shows a split picture. In mathematics, the school's overall proficiency sits at roughly the midpoint. In English language arts, proficiency is substantially lower, at roughly a third. Science proficiency, most recently reported, is the school's strongest area, sitting well above half. When these three subject proficiency rates are averaged, Reid ranks in the top quartile among Dauphin County elementary schools in overall proficiency. This means Reid performs better than the majority of comparable schools in the county, though readers will want context: the state testing data captures only grades 3 through 5, so performance is not uniform across the building. The lower English language arts number suggests that reading instruction is a point of focus.
The district has initiated a major elementary restructuring that directly affects Reid's future. A new consolidated primary school opening in fall 2026 will house kindergarten through third grade across the district. When that happens, Reid will convert to a grade 4-5 only campus and shift to a departmentalized instructional model where students rotate between subject-area teachers rather than stay in self-contained classrooms. This change reshapes both what the school becomes and where younger siblings would attend. It also accompanies a district-wide literacy curriculum overhaul in grades K-5 using evidence-based reading instruction strategies, which may influence the trajectory of proficiency in early grades and upstream effects on upper elementary.
Middletown itself is a dense, walkable small town with a recognizable downtown centered on Main Street, a historic character mix of log houses and Victorian homes, and a rental-dominant housing market. The community has an active economic base: Harrisburg International Airport is located within Middletown, Penn State Harrisburg operates a branch campus on the edge of town, and major employers include healthcare systems, manufacturers like TE Connectivity and Phoenix Contact, and recently Constellation Energy announced plans to restart the nearby Three Mile Island nuclear generating station. The Amtrak Keystone Service runs through a newly rebuilt station, opened in 2022, connecting Middletown to Harrisburg and points beyond. Population has been roughly stable over recent years, with modest new residential construction active in the surrounding market.
Housing costs in the Middletown zip code are moderate relative to the state and national median, and monthly mortgage estimates and rents sit somewhat below state benchmarks, making the area accessible for families with mid-range incomes. The local unemployment rate is steady and the economic backdrop is stable.
Robert Reid is poised at a moment of change. Its classroom teaching practice is being reformed at the literacy level, and its grades 4-5 instructional delivery is shifting toward a subject-focused rotation that mirrors middle school. For families with kindergarten through third-grade children, a relocated school building will become their child's entry point. Parents considering Reid should weigh both the current proficiency data—particularly the English language arts performance and the context that reading instruction is evolving district-wide—and the structural transition ahead.
See more original research from School Decision →