The top reported proficiency rate is 80% in Science. The lowest is 50% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on James F Baugher El Sch
James F Baugher Elementary is a neighborhood school serving kindergarten through fourth grade in Milton, a small industrial borough on the West Branch Susquehanna River. The school sits at the center of Milton Area School District, which spans two counties and has been navigating property-tax reassessments and facility changes over recent years. Baugher itself completed a major renovation that temporarily displaced fifth graders during the 2022-2023 school year, and the building is now home to a fresh K-5 reading curriculum adopted in 2024 and a developing partnership with the Greater Susquehanna Valley YMCA for before-and-after-school programming.
The school enrolls a modest population of about five hundred students, distributed fairly evenly across kindergarten through fourth grade. Just over half of the student body qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic circumstances of Milton, where manufacturing, warehousing, and health care anchor the local job market but long-term population has declined from its industrial heyday. The student body is predominantly white, with a growing Hispanic population and smaller numbers of students from other backgrounds, including multiracial students. Data on special education enrollment and English learner identification were not available.
On state assessments in math and English language arts, administered to grades three through four, the school shows uneven results. About half of students met proficiency in math, and roughly the same proportion reached proficiency in English language arts. Science performance, last measured in the prior school year, was notably stronger, with the bulk of students meeting proficiency. When considered together, the school's overall proficiency across tested subjects places it in the top quartile among Northumberland County districts, a distinction that reflects solid science performance offsetting lower results in reading and math. A parent evaluating this school should look into what the district is doing with the new K-5 reading curriculum to address the lower ELA numbers and ask how the YMCA partnership might support skill-building in the before-school hours.
Milton itself is a walkable historic borough centered on a grid of Front and Broadway streets, with civic life anchored downtown at the Milton Public Library, Rose Hill (a cultural venue), and along the Susquehanna riverfront at Lincoln Park and Milton State Park. The town retains a substantial number of late Victorian and early twentieth-century buildings, and its identity remains tied to manufacturing, most famously as the original home of Chef Boyardee, with Conagra still operating a factory there. Housing values in the broader zip code are below both the state and national median, and the borough has recently pursued scattered-site housing rehabilitation using federal HOME funds rather than large new residential development, a pattern suggesting modest growth rather than expansion. Public transit is limited to an on-demand shuttle service, so most families in the area drive.
The district serves both Milton and surrounding towns split across Northumberland and Union counties. Both counties are undertaking property reassessments—the first in Northumberland approved in late 2024 and the second in Union County now underway, with new values taking effect in 2028—driven in part by large disparities in property taxes within the Milton Area School District itself. Because school levies must be equalized between the two counties, these reassessments will reshape what families pay in school taxes for years to come. A family considering this school may want to understand the district's long-term financial outlook in light of these changes.
See more original research from School Decision →