The top reported proficiency rate is 87% in Science. The lowest is 37% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Donegal El Sch
Donegal Elementary serves kindergarten through fourth grade in Jones Mills, a small rural village nestled in the Laurel Highlands of Westmoreland County. The school draws from a low-density, dispersed community centered on a Route 31 crossroads rather than a traditional town center. The enrollment is small, with roughly equal distribution across the lower grades except a slight taper in the upper elementary years, and the student body is predominantly white with a substantial share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch.
In academic terms, the school shows a split picture. Science performance is strong, with most students reaching proficiency on state assessment. Math and reading (ELA) present different challenges. In math, the proficiency rate sits below half, and in reading it falls lower still. These numbers reflect genuine learning gaps that a parent may want to discuss directly with the school to understand how the building is addressing them. When stacked against other elementary schools across Westmoreland County's districts, Donegal's overall proficiency index places it above the midpoint, meaning it is performing better than many rural and smaller schools in the county while trailing the county's higher-performing schools. State testing data by grade level, participation rates, and trend information were not available, so it is unclear whether progress is steady, whether particular grades struggle more than others, or how results have moved over time.
The school sits within Mount Pleasant Area School District, which covers a wider swath of Westmoreland County. The district is in a sustained period of property tax increases, with the millage rate rising annually over the past several cycles. Parents should understand that this upward pressure is expected to continue, making the cost of school residence a real factor for families considering the area. Beyond property tax, the district is managing outflow to cyber charter schools, a structural cost that is constraining overall finances and driving down the fund balance. These pressures do not directly affect classroom instruction at Donegal, but they do signal the fiscal environment in which the school and district operate.
Jones Mills itself is quiet and mountain-bound, with outdoor recreation anchored by state forest lands, Donegal Lake, and Roaring Run Natural Area. The village has no downtown in the conventional sense; civic life centers on the township municipal building off Route 31. Employment is tied to Seven Springs Mountain Resort (now part of Vail Resorts), coal mining, and state forest management, giving the area a resource-and-tourism economy. Growth has been minimal; the township remains low-density and sparsely developed. There is no fixed-route public transit.
For a family considering this school, the appeal lies in its rural, tight-knit character and outdoor setting. Parents whose children need high support in reading or math instruction should have a direct conversation with the school about intervention strategies. Families should also factor in the district's tax trajectory as part of the long-term cost of living in the area. The school's small size and modest enrollment mean limited program breadth at the elementary level, which is typical for rural K-4 buildings; if specialized services or enrichment programs beyond core instruction are important to a family, they would want to verify what is available before enrollment.
See more original research from School Decision →