The top reported proficiency rate is 97% in Science. The lowest is 60% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Neshannock Memorial El Sch
Neshannock Memorial Elementary serves grades kindergarten through sixth in New Castle, the county seat of Lawrence County and a post-industrial city shaped by steel mills, fireworks manufacturing, and strong Italian and Greek immigrant heritage. The school sits on Mitchell Road and draws from a surrounding area of older residential neighborhoods built around a downtown core that once anchored regional commerce and still hosts government and civic functions.
The school's enrollment is stable at just under seven hundred students, distributed fairly evenly across its seven grades. About a third of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the modest household incomes in this part of western Pennsylvania. The student body is predominantly white; students of color make up a small share of enrollment. Data on special education and English learner populations was not available.
In state testing on the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment, the school's proficiency results are mixed across subjects. In reading and language arts, about two-thirds of tested students in grades three through six reached proficient or advanced levels. In mathematics, proficiency sits a bit lower, with about three-fifths meeting proficiency standards. Science results stand apart—nearly all students tested achieved proficient or advanced performance, indicating strong instruction or curriculum in that subject. When proficiency rates are averaged across all tested subjects and grades, the school ranks in the top quartile among the eight other districts in Lawrence County.
The district that runs this school has faced real property-tax and infrastructure decisions. In 2023-24 the board approved a modest property tax increase along with substantial borrowing to fund campus improvements, raising costs on typical homeowners. The following year the board voted to hold tax rates flat despite legal authority to raise them further, offering temporary relief. Separately, the district completed a multi-year overhaul of heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning systems across its buildings between 2020 and 2021, replacing heat pumps, adding outside air handlers, installing new ventilation units in all elementary classrooms, and upgrading building controls to exceed the standards set by ASHRAE for public schools. That work means the elementary school's air quality and climate control now meet or exceed current professional standards for student health and comfort.
New Castle itself is a city in steady population decline, shrinking over the past few decades as manufacturing jobs left the region. Housing is older—most homes predate the 1940s—and median home values and rents sit well below state and national benchmarks, making the area affordable for families on modest incomes. The city's trajectory centers on downtown revitalization rather than new residential growth. In 2023, Lawrence County was added to the Pittsburgh Metropolitan Statistical Area, a structural shift that may signal longer-term economic reorientation toward the Pittsburgh region.
A parent choosing this school should expect a neighborhood elementary with grounded proficiency in reading and strong proficiency in science, modest proficiency in math, and a student body that reflects the local community's demographic character. The school operates within a district managing ongoing capital needs and property-tax constraints typical of older industrial towns. No information was available about specific academic programs, instructional approach, student support services, or other operational features that would help paint a fuller picture of daily school life.
See more original research from School Decision →