The top reported proficiency rate is 63% in Science. The lowest is 24% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Washington Intrmd Sch
Washington Intermediate School serves grades three through five in New Castle, a shrinking post-industrial city that is the county seat of Lawrence County. The school sits in the heart of a community with deep industrial and immigrant heritage, where most housing stock predates midcentury and median home values sit well below state and national averages. Downtown New Castle is undergoing a revitalization centered on the Cascade Center and restored historic buildings, but the city's population has declined substantially over the past two decades. The school enrolls students across a modest geographic footprint of the Lawrence County region.
The student body at Washington Intermediate is entirely eligible for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating a school serving families with low household incomes. The enrollment is diverse: just over half the students identify as white, and the remainder are distributed among Black, multiracial, Hispanic, and Asian populations, with multiracial students representing about a quarter of the enrollment. The school sits at the center of economic conditions that shape the families it serves.
State testing data reveals uneven academic performance. In English language arts and mathematics, proficiency is low: roughly one in four students in grades three through five meets state standards in reading, and fewer than one in three meet standards in math. Science results stand apart, with a substantially higher proficiency rate that exceeds two in three students. This split between strong science performance and weaker literacy and numeracy results suggests particular instructional strengths in science curriculum or pedagogy, but also signals that a majority of students in ELA and math may need additional support to reach grade-level expectations. When compared against other districts in Lawrence County, Washington Intermediate's overall proficiency index falls in the bottom quartile, meaning its combined performance across tested subjects ranks below the median for the county.
The school's parent district, New Castle Area School District, has navigated a period of fiscal stability but now faces pressure. The district held property tax rates flat for an extended span but is moving toward increases beginning in the 2025-26 school year to address a substantial projected deficit. That shortfall stems from the expiration of federal COVID-19 relief funds, rising costs associated with students leaving for charter schools, and health care expenses growing at roughly double-digit annual rates. For families considering the district, this signals a transition from an era of stable school taxes toward recurring increases and ongoing budget constraints that may affect program and service capacity over time.
A parent evaluating Washington Intermediate should understand that this is a neighborhood elementary school in a low-income community facing significant academic gaps in core literacy and math skills, even as the school demonstrates competence in science instruction. The school and district face resource headwinds that are likely to shape operational decisions in the near term. The broader New Castle context is one of economic decline and downtown-focused revitalization rather than growth, which affects both housing stability and community resources that families may draw on.
See more original research from School Decision →