The top reported proficiency rate is 55% in Science. The lowest is 31% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Pittsburgh Carmalt K-8
Pittsburgh Carmalt K-8 serves a small, economically concentrated student body in one of Pittsburgh's neighborhoods. The school enrolls students from pre-kindergarten through eighth grade, with roughly a third in the lower elementary grades, a smaller cohort in middle school, and a substantial share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. The racial and ethnic composition is diverse, with roughly equal shares of Black and white students, a smaller Asian enrollment, and students identifying as two or more races.
On state testing, Carmalt's results sit below the midpoint for schools in Allegheny County. In English language arts, the most recent data shows that a minority of students achieved proficiency. Math proficiency is notably lower, with about three in ten students reaching proficient or above. Science data from a prior year showed a stronger result, with about half the students proficient. The school administered these state assessments to a tested group of students in grades three through eight; science testing involved a smaller cohort than math and ELA, which is typical when not all grades sit for that assessment.
The district context around Carmalt involves significant structural change. Pittsburgh Public Schools is undergoing a facilities consolidation and closure plan approved in May 2026, which will close nine school buildings by the end of 2027 and restructure grade configurations citywide. Carmalt itself is not on the closure list, but feeder patterns, magnet program access, and neighborhood assignment boundaries are shifting. The district recently moved all elementary students to an Open Court Reading curriculum centered on phonics and foundational skills, replacing an earlier program; this represents a deliberate pedagogical shift in how students learn to read in the early grades. Additionally, the Pittsburgh Promise scholarship program—which historically provided college funding to PPS graduates—will end for students graduating after 2028, removing a longstanding college-access benefit for new families. In late 2025, the district approved a property tax increase to address budget pressures tied to enrollment decline and commercial assessment appeals.
The housing market in the school's area reflects a modest price point within the Pittsburgh metro. Home values in the zip code are below both the state and national median, and rental costs are moderate. The neighborhood itself is part of Pittsburgh's patchwork of distinct communities; the city is organized around a dense downtown mixed with roughly ninety residential neighborhoods, each with distinct character. School choice in Pittsburgh is being narrowed by the consolidation, with elementary magnet programs being phased out and greater reliance on neighborhood assignments.
For a family considering Carmalt, the school offers coverage of pre-K through eighth grade in a regular public setting with a student population that reflects significant economic and demographic diversity. The academic proficiency numbers, particularly in math, signal that achievement gaps exist and may warrant conversation with the school about how it supports students working below grade level. The district's ongoing curriculum work in reading and the broader facilities restructuring represent a period of transition—changes that create both opportunity and uncertainty about how they will affect individual schools.
See more original research from School Decision →