The top reported proficiency rate is 79% in Science. The lowest is 35% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on South St Marys Street El Sch
South St Marys Street Elementary serves children from pre-K through fifth grade in a small Pennsylvania city with a manufacturing economy and a compact, walkable historic downtown. The school sits within the Saint Marys Area School District, which covers a mid-sized rural and suburban area.
The enrollment is modest, with the school serving a total population across its grade band. Every student in the building qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, making this a school where economic need is universal and uniform. The student body is predominantly white, with small numbers of students from other racial and ethnic backgrounds. Data on students receiving special education services or English learner support was not available.
On state assessments, the school shows a split picture. In science, the most recent available results show strong performance, well above what you would typically expect. In math, proficiency sits at around the middle of the range. English language arts performance is notably lower, with less than half of tested students meeting proficiency standards. The school's overall proficiency index places it above the midpoint among districts in Elk County, its comparison peer group. Trend data was not available, so it is unclear whether these results represent improvement, stability, or decline from prior years.
The district has been making deliberate instructional changes at this school. South St Marys Street Elementary recently implemented new science and math curricula and is analyzing its reading program for the coming year. The school is also using universal screeners five times annually to benchmark student progress, an approach that aims to catch gaps early and guide instruction. These shifts suggest the district is responding to performance and rethinking how core subjects are taught.
The town itself is economically grounded. Saint Marys is known as the powdered metal capital of the world, with major manufacturing operations including international carbon and graphite companies, a large thermistor facility, and established breweries. The historic downtown has held up better than many small Pennsylvania towns, with a thriving business district, walkable streets, shops, restaurants, and community anchors like the public library, parks, and a boys and girls club. Housing values are well below state and national benchmarks, making homeownership more accessible, though the district recently ended a long tax freeze and raised property taxes three years in a row, shifting the cost structure for families in the district. This is a material change for homeowners to factor into their calculation.
The school population is economically stressed. With every student eligible for free lunch, this is a community facing genuine hardship. At the same time, the district is investing in instructional improvement and the town is in a phase of modest economic growth, with manufacturing facilities expanding and the municipal government growing its capacity. A parent considering this school should expect a place focused on academic fundamentals in a community where resources are tight but not absent, with deliberate curriculum work underway and a small-school environment where the peer group is predominantly white and economically homogeneous.
See more original research from School Decision →