The top reported proficiency rate is 82% in Math. The lowest is 76% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Burchfield Primary Sch
Burchfield Primary School serves kindergarten through third grade in Allison Park, a residential suburb about 12 miles north of Pittsburgh. The school enrolls a small cohort, nearly all of whom are white, with roughly a quarter of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is primarily drawn from families homeowning in the surrounding area, where single-family residential neighborhoods dominate the landscape and car dependency is high.
Academically, Burchfield's third-grade proficiency results on Pennsylvania's state assessment are notably strong. In math, the school's proficiency rate places it in the top quartile among schools tested in Allegheny County. English language arts proficiency is somewhat lower but still solid. When the two subjects are averaged, Burchfield sits well above the median proficiency index for schools across the county. These are the only state-tested grades the school serves, so longer academic trajectories and outcomes beyond grade 3 are not visible from this data.
The district, Shaler Area School District, serves four municipalities: Etna, Millvale, Reserve, and Shaler. It is undergoing a significant structural reconfiguration called "Building for Tomorrow," closing Shaler Area Elementary and converting its four primary schools (Burchfield, Marzolf, Reserve, and Scott) into full K-5 neighborhood schools beginning in 2026-27. This means families currently with a child at Burchfield and younger children entering kindergarten will see those younger siblings continue at Burchfield rather than moving to a separate elementary school as was previously the pattern. The change is being driven by enrollment decline over the past several years, and it represents the largest operational shift in the district since its merger.
The property tax environment has shifted noticeably. After increases in 2023-24 and 2024-25, the board held the millage flat for 2025-26. A homeowner should expect that the cumulative tax adjustments from the prior two years represent a lasting, meaningful increase in the annual school portion of the property tax bill.
The district is making a concentrated investment in how early reading is taught. All K-3 teachers are receiving LETRS training and the district has adopted a Science of Reading-aligned approach to primary literacy instruction districtwide. This is a direct pedagogical change that affects how every child in grades kindergarten through third learns to read at Burchfield.
At the secondary level, the middle school is undergoing a major capital renovation: roof replacement, HVAC installation including air conditioning, a new fire alarm system, and interior renovations to flooring, ceilings, and lighting. Construction is expected to begin in summer 2026. This work signals the district's commitment to long-term facility improvement and debt service, and children who move from Burchfield to the middle school after third grade will step into a substantially upgraded building environment.
The Allison Park housing market is moderate and stable. Homes are priced modestly below the Pennsylvania state benchmark and well below the national median, making the area accessible for families seeking suburban school settings. The market has seen modest recent softening, but remains active. Rent is also accessible relative to median household income in the region.
Burchfield is a small primary school in a district navigating substantial change: a shift in grade configuration, a commitment to early literacy reform, and meaningful capital investment in its secondary facilities. It fits families seeking a neighborhood K-5 elementary with solid early academic performance in a car-dependent suburban setting with moderate housing costs.
See more original research from School Decision →