The top reported proficiency rate is 53% in English language arts. The lowest is 48% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Southmoreland Ms
Southmoreland Middle School sits in Scottdale, a small Westmoreland County borough about a short drive southeast of Pittsburgh with a historic downtown and residential neighborhoods shaped by its past as a coke and rail hub. The town has a walkable grid centered on Pittsburgh Street, home to preserved 19th and early-20th-century brick buildings, though the area's industrial economy has largely faded. Most residents now work in health care or retail; Duraloy Technologies, a specialty alloy foundry, is the last significant manufacturing remnant. Housing is affordable and stable, with a small, slow-moving market where homes linger longer than in faster-growing areas.
The school itself is housed in a converted 1880s building—the former Scottdale Joint High School, renovated when the district merged Scottdale and East Huntingdon schools in the early 2000s. The middle grades live in a fairly uniform peer environment: nearly all students are white, and about three-fifths qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, pointing to a working-class student body where economic hardship is widespread. The student enrollment is small for the three grades it serves, ranging from roughly mid-size to slightly below mid-size for a middle school.
Academically, Southmoreland Middle School performs at a middling level relative to other middle schools and districts in Westmoreland County. In the most recent data available, roughly half of students tested at or above proficiency in English language arts, and about half in mathematics. Science proficiency, last measured two years ago, sat at roughly the same level. The school's overall proficiency index places it above the midpoint among the county's district middle schools, a respectable showing that reflects work the school has done closing gaps and raising floors. The Pennsylvania Department of Education publicly reported that the school far exceeded the state's predicted proficiency rates for 2024-25, earning it recognition as a 2025 Pennsylvania Blue Ribbon School in the inaugural state cohort, a distinction awarded to fewer than twenty schools statewide. That recognition signals that the school is performing better than district demographics alone would predict, meaning the school is getting more out of students than similar peer groups elsewhere.
However, parents should note that absolute proficiency rates, while respectable and improving, still leave a meaningful share of students below grade level in both math and reading. If your child arrives at sixth grade behind, the school's support systems and what paths it offers to students working below grade-level benchmarks would be worth exploring directly with administrators.
The district maintains an affordability advantage: housing values are well below the state and national benchmarks, and property is notably cheaper here than across Westmoreland County generally. The trade-off is that the school district levies property taxes to support operations, and residents have absorbed two consecutive years of increases, a fact worth understanding if you own property in the service area.
Scottdale itself offers a tight-knit, quiet community feel with parks, a public library, a restored opera house hosting community theater, and a five-mile rails-to-trails bike path. Civic life clusters around the historic downtown, though the secondary schools are located outside the borough proper—the high school sits in nearby Alverton. The town's population is essentially flat, and new housing development is minimal; reinvestment has focused on adaptive reuse of old buildings rather than new construction. This is a stable, modest place where change comes slowly and housing stock is older and preserved rather than new.
See more original research from School Decision →