The top reported proficiency rate is 39% in Science. The lowest is 12% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Steelton-highspire El Sch
Steelton-Highspire Elementary School is a small, neighborhood-based K–6 school serving roughly three-quarters of a thousand students from Steelton and nearby areas in Dauphin County. The school sits on Reynders Avenue within the borough's compact, walkable grid, alongside the district's only other building, a junior/senior high school a few blocks away. It is a regular public elementary school with no charter or magnet designation.
Student composition is predominantly Black and Hispanic, with smaller representation of White students and two-or-more-race students. Enrollment is stable across the six grade bands served, meaning each grade has roughly similar cohort sizes. Free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility data was not available, but the broader Steelton context—a post-industrial borough with working-class demographics and a median household income below the state average—indicates that many families likely qualify for lunch support.
Academic performance is the most significant factor any parent should weigh carefully. On the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment for grades 3–8, the school's proficiency in math and English language arts is substantially low. In the most recent year available, proficiency in math was in the low double digits, and in ELA in the high single digits. Science proficiency, measured in an earlier year, was notably higher, closer to mid-range. Against other elementary schools in Dauphin County, the overall proficiency index places this school below the midpoint. The gap between performance here and the county average is material and direct.
The district context matters significantly. In March 2025, the Pennsylvania Department of Education designated Steelton-Highspire as being in Financial Recovery, appointing a state Chief Recovery Officer to guide long-term planning. This is not the same as routine budget tightness; it signals structural financial and operational challenges that will reshape staffing, programming, and resource allocation across both schools for years. Both the elementary and secondary schools in the district also carry state accountability designations (CSI/A-TSI) tied to academic underperformance, placing them in a multi-year school improvement framework.
The district adopted a 2024–2027 Comprehensive Plan to reset curriculum and instruction priorities, meaning teaching approaches and course content are being actively revised. For an elementary school family, that represents both an intervention effort and a period of transition.
The borough itself is actively revitalizing. Front Street, the traditional downtown spine, is the focus of an EPA-backed brownfields redevelopment plan. Mixed-use housing, retail, and community space projects are in construction or planning phases. Transit access is available via the rabbittransit system, with routes connecting Steelton to Harrisburg and regional destinations. Parks, a community-owned skatepark, and civic gathering spaces are walkable from school neighborhoods. Housing values in the zip code are well below county and state medians, making the area affordable for families seeking entry-level purchases or rentals. The major employer—the steel mill—permanently closed its rail production in 2025 after a century-plus presence, so the economic foundation of the community has shifted.
This school is best suited for a family committed to Steelton's future or already embedded in the community, who understands that their children will attend a school in active academic intervention, with low current proficiency across core subjects, and that schooling here happens in the context of district-level financial recovery. If you are drawn to the walkable, diverse neighborhood character and affordability, and you plan to be engaged in supporting your child's learning while the school and district work through their turnaround plan, it is worth a direct conversation with school leadership about curriculum, support services, and the specific outlook for your child's grade band. If your priority is immediate strong academic performance in math and reading, or a school with no accountability constraints, this is not the fit.
See more original research from School Decision →