The top reported proficiency rate is 80% in Science. The lowest is 52% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Main Street Elementary School
Main Street Elementary serves first through fifth graders in a small western Pennsylvania city where the oil industry was born. The school sits in Titusville, a compact community centered on a walkable downtown with tree-lined Victorian brick storefronts, in the far eastern corner of Crawford County. It is a regular public elementary school in the Titusville Area School District, which spans three counties and has deliberately built an in-house online and blended-learning option called Rockets Online Campus since 2021, offering families an alternative to outside cyber charters.
The school enrolls about a quarter-thousand students across its grade band. A substantial share of families qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting economic conditions across the community. The student population is predominantly white, with small shares of students identifying as Hispanic or multiracial. Counts for special-education and English-learner populations were not available, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about support structures for students who need them.
In recent state testing, Main Street's results have been mixed. On the most recent math and English-language arts assessments for grades three through five, a little more than half of tested students met proficiency standards in each subject. Science results from an earlier year showed substantially stronger performance, with most students meeting standards. The school's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile among districts in Crawford County, meaning it outperforms the median on combined results across tested subjects.
The broader Titusville community is navigating a revitalization phase rather than rapid growth. Downtown anchors around the Benson Memorial Library, which holds local history collections. Oil Creek State Park and the Drake Well Museum lie minutes away and serve as outdoor community draws. The town emphasizes placemaking focused on revitalization, public art, and housing strategy. Median home values are well below the state average, making homeownership more accessible than many Pennsylvania communities, though property taxes have been rising in recent years in the Crawford County part of the district due to a state-mandated multi-district rebalancing process. A parent relocating to the area should confirm which county section of the district they fall in, because tax changes differ by county within the same district.
Main Street is small enough that families have a good sense of the school's day-to-day operations and community feel, yet large enough to offer a full elementary program across five grades. The school operates within a district that is deliberately investing in choice through its Rockets Online Campus, meaning families are not locked into a single pedagogical model. A parent visiting would encounter a traditional neighborhood elementary in a town with a stable, older housing stock and a quiet pace of life.
See more original research from School Decision →