The top reported proficiency rate is 83% in Science. The lowest is 53% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Union Memorial El Sch
Union Memorial Elementary School serves preschool through fifth grade in New Castle, Pennsylvania, a county seat and historic small city shaped by industrial heritage and strong ethnic immigrant communities. The school enrolls a small student population that is predominantly white, with a complete Title I footprint: all enrolled students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. New Castle itself is a shrinking post-industrial city where downtown revitalization efforts and older housing stock define the landscape, and a smaller share of homes are owner-occupied single-family detached units compared to national norms.
The school's academic standing is mixed. In math and English language arts, students in grades three through five score near or slightly above the midpoint among Lawrence County district schools. In math, about half the students tested met proficiency standards; in ELA, the rate was somewhat lower. Science results, the most recent available from the prior testing cycle, showed stronger performance, with a clear majority of students proficient. Testing participation rates and scale score data were not available, so a fuller picture of student growth and assessment depth cannot be drawn from the data at hand.
When proficiency is averaged across all tested subjects and grades, Union Memorial places in the top quartile among its county peers, a position that reflects the science results pulling the overall index upward and offsetting weaker ELA performance. This is genuine strength in comparison to other schools in Lawrence County, though parents may want to look into the divergence between the school's stronger science performance and its more modest literacy results, and what instructional support the school has in place for ELA specifically.
The student body is small, with roughly equal grade-level cohorts between kindergarten and fifth grade and a smaller preschool group. The school's composition is reflective of New Castle's own demographics: the vast majority of students are white, with a smaller representation of Black and multiracial students, and very few Hispanic or Asian students. Every student qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, which signals both the economic conditions of the families served and the school's role as a key support structure in its community.
Union Area School District, which operates Union Memorial, has undertaken significant infrastructure investment in recent years. After holding property taxes flat for several years, the district approved back-to-back increases to its millage rate starting in the 2023-24 school year, with the rate holding stable since then at its current level. The district also authorized substantial general obligation notes for facility improvements and committed unassigned fund balance reserves to capital projects, PSERS pension obligations, and health care costs. This financial repositioning is durable and reflects a multi-year commitment to school facilities and operations that families considering the district would encounter through their tax bills and see reflected in school infrastructure. The district serves only New Castle, so the school's performance and context are effectively inseparable from the town itself.
Parents considering Union Memorial should weigh the school's stronger science standing against its more modest literacy results, understand the stable-but-elevated tax posture the district has adopted, and recognize that the school serves a fully economically disadvantaged population in a community where housing values are below state and national medians, where employment centers on healthcare, education, government, and some remaining manufacturing, and where post-industrial revitalization rather than growth is the development story.
See more original research from School Decision →