The top reported proficiency rate is 95% in Science. The lowest is 88% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Donaldson Elem Sch
Donaldson Elementary is a school of about mid-size enrollment serving kindergarten through fifth grade in Oakdale, a small residential borough west of Pittsburgh. The school is part of West Allegheny School District, which spans Oakdale and the neighboring borough of Imperial.
The academic picture is strong. In math, students in grades three through five scored at a proficiency level that places the school in the top quartile among Allegheny County elementary schools. English language arts proficiency also runs high. Science results, from an earlier year, were similarly robust. The overall proficiency index across tested subjects positions Donaldson well above the county median for elementary schools.
The student body is predominantly white and draws from the immediate residential area. About one-quarter of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, suggesting a mixed socioeconomic composition within a working- to middle-class suburb. The school serves students across all six grade bands represented, with fairly balanced enrollment at each level.
Donaldson sits within a district that has made two moves worth noting for families. West Allegheny was designated a national "Lighthouse" district in 2022 for its Early College in High School Academy, which offers college-credit pathways in healthcare, business, education, engineering, skilled trades, and aviation. That program operates at the high school level, but it reflects the district's orientation toward career-aligned academics and dual-credit opportunity. Second, the district held property tax millage flat in its 2024-2025 budget cycle, a stance that contrasts with most other Allegheny County districts, which raised taxes. For parents, this means no property tax increase at the district level that year.
The immediate community is quiet and walkable in the historic borough center but car-dependent for shopping and employment. Most families commute to jobs elsewhere in the Pittsburgh area. Oakdale experienced the closure of Pittsburgh Technical College in August 2024, a significant institutional loss, though the site's future development may shape the area over time. Housing in the zip code runs in the mid-range for the region, with home values relatively stable and rental costs consistent with a working-class suburb.
At the middle school level, the district completed a full renovation and expansion of West Allegheny Middle School in March 2025, redesigning the building with collaborative learning spaces, flexible teaching areas, and features like an instructional "Think Tank." That facilities upgrade is direct and lasting for students moving into grades six through eight.
Donaldson itself is a neighborhood elementary school with solid academic performance, a stable student body, and access to a district infrastructure that emphasizes both college readiness and career pathways. Data on special populations such as English learners or students with IEPs was not available, so a parent may want to look into that further with the school. The result is a school that fits families seeking a traditional public elementary option in a suburban, academically sound setting.
See more original research from School Decision →