The top reported proficiency rate is 62% in Math. The lowest is 47% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Clara Barton El Sch
Clara Barton Elementary serves kindergarten through third grade in West Mifflin, a residential suburban borough southeast of Pittsburgh anchored by historic steel-era roots. The school enrolls a small community of students, nearly all of whom qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is predominantly white, with meaningful representation of students identifying as two or more races, Black students, and smaller numbers of Asian and Hispanic students.
West Mifflin itself is car-oriented, hilly, and wooded territory with no walkable downtown. Civic and school facilities are dispersed along arterial roads. The borough has experienced slow population decline over time, and the landscape bears marks of its industrial past, with terrain shaped by historic steel-mill byproducts. The major development story currently unfolding is the demolition and planned redevelopment of the former Century III Mall, a roughly ninety-acre site that demolition crews began razing in early 2024, with completion forecast for 2026 and major new construction potentially beginning in late 2026 or 2027. The Mon/Fayette Expressway extension is also under active construction across the borough. Major employers include the Bettis Atomic Power Laboratory, Kennywood amusement park, U.S. Steel's Irvin Works, and retail chains; Pittsburgh Regional Transit operates bus routes through the area.
On state assessments in grades three through eight, Clara Barton's proficiency rate in math stands above the midpoint among elementary and middle schools across Allegheny County's school districts, while proficiency in English language arts is below that midpoint. The disparity between math and reading performance is substantial enough that a parent may want to explore with the school what reading supports exist and how the school is addressing it. The school does not serve high school grades, so no graduation rate applies. Special education and English learner enrollment data were not available in the public record.
The district that operates Clara Barton is currently studying a major building consolidation proposal that would fundamentally restructure the school configuration. Under that proposal, Clara Barton would be converted into the district's administration building, with kindergarten through sixth grade students moving into the middle school building. This plan remains under study and has not been adopted, but it signals significant change on the horizon for families considering enrollment. The consolidation study was prompted by underlying budget pressure: a Century III Mall property tax settlement and ongoing commercial real estate refunds have created an anticipated income loss in a single year, plus a projected budget deficit approaching tens of millions of dollars for the 2025–26 school year. The district has held its real estate tax millage rate flat through multiple recent budget cycles, meaning stable school property tax bills for several running years, but that stability reflects the choice not to raise taxes rather than healthy surplus. A parent weighing a move to West Mifflin should inquire directly with the district about the timing and likelihood of the consolidation proposal, as it could affect which school their child attends.
See more original research from School Decision →