The top reported proficiency rate is 27% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Jamesville Colony Elementary - 03
Jamesville Colony Elementary sits on a rural route near Utica, South Dakota, and serves kindergarten through eighth grade as part of the Menno School District 33-2. The name tells much of the story: this is a colony school, the kind of small, isolated schoolhouse that serves a single Hutterite community on its own land. With roughly two dozen students spread across nine grade levels, the classrooms here are small by any standard, and the peer group is tight and homogeneous. Every enrolled student is white, and the school draws entirely from the colony itself rather than from the surrounding town.
Utica is a tiny residential dot on the map in Yankton County, sitting northwest of the city of Yankton near the Missouri River and Lewis and Clark Lake. Publicly reported data describe a community with no real commercial corridor, no downtown core, and very low housing density. The population has been small and gradually declining, with the most recent American Community Survey estimate placing it well below its 2020 census count. There is no walkability infrastructure, no public library, and no local transit. Residents who need goods, services, or employment generally look toward Yankton. The Utica Municipal Building serves as the only civic anchor. It is worth noting that while Utica proper is associated with the Yankton School District for its residential students, Jamesville Colony Elementary falls under the separate Menno district, reflecting how colony schools operate on their own geographic and organizational terms.
On state assessments, the school's results are limited by the very small number of students tested each year. In the most recent year, only a handful of third-through-eighth graders took the SBAC math and English language arts exams, and roughly a quarter of those tested reached proficiency in each subject. Science results were suppressed by the state, likely because too few students sat for the exam to report a reliable figure. Full participation was recorded among those who were tested. With such small testing groups, a single student's performance shifts the proficiency rate substantially, making year-to-year comparisons unstable. There is no multi-year trend data available to contextualize whether these results represent a pattern or a one-year snapshot. A parent may want to look into this further with the school, particularly how instruction is delivered across so many grade levels in such a small setting.
The school does not serve high school grades, so there is no graduation rate to report. Free-or-reduced-price lunch counts, special education rates, and English learner figures were all missing from available data, which is common for colony schools where the community handles much of its own social fabric and the reporting universe is tiny. No data on staffing ratios, course offerings, discipline, or attendance was available. Program offerings were not reported. Civil rights data was absent. No neighbor comparison set was provided for this school.
The Menno School District, which oversees this school, had no publicly reported parent-relevant changes such as referendums, curriculum shifts, or facility plans in recent reporting. The district brief turned up little beyond basic profile information.
What this school offers is a specific and narrow pathway. It is a colony school serving a closed, faith-based rural community, and it functions within that context. Families considering it are almost certainly part of the colony itself. For an outside family looking in, the data gaps and the tiny testing cohort make it difficult to draw firm academic conclusions, and the setting is one that answers to a way of life rather than to open enrollment.
See more original research from School Decision →