The top reported proficiency rate is 12% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Maxwell Colony Elementary - 04
Maxwell Colony Elementary - 04 sits in Scotland, South Dakota, part of the Menno School District 33-2. It serves kindergarten through eighth grade in a very small setting, with just a handful of students per grade level. The school's name and profile point to a Hutterite colony school, a common arrangement in South Dakota where colony communities operate their own small schools within the public district structure. This shapes nearly everything about what the school is and who it serves.
The student body is entirely white, and nearly all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which reflects the communal economic structure of colony life rather than the kind of income disparity you might see in a more conventional school. The enrollment is small enough that each grade has only a few children, and the whole school could fit in a couple of classrooms. There is no charter or magnet designation; it is a regular public school operating within the district.
On state assessments, the most recent results show low proficiency in both math and English language arts, with only a small fraction of tested students reaching proficient or above in each subject. Science results were suppressed, likely due to the small number of test-takers. Full participation was reported for the math and ELA assessments, so the low scores are not a function of students skipping the test. These are straightforward results, and a parent considering this school may want to look into how the school supports academic growth and what instructional approaches are used with such small, multi-age groupings. The school does not serve high school grades, so there is no graduation rate to report, and no AP, dual-credit, or career-pathway data applies here.
Beyond academics, the data is thin. We have no information on staffing ratios, discipline practices, attendance, course access, or special populations such as English learners or students with individualized education programs. The school environment and access section returned no locale classification, no Title I status, and no civil rights data. Programs data was not provided, so there is nothing to report on extracurriculars, arts, or additional services.
The community and economic context is also largely absent. Web research aimed at Scotland, South Dakota returned information about the country of Scotland rather than the town, so we have no usable detail on local employers, walkability, civic anchors, or growth and development. Housing values and rents were not available in the data. We looked for parent-relevant changes in the Menno School District, such as referendums, curriculum shifts, or property tax adjustments, and found none reported, so we left that out rather than guess.
No neighbor comparison fact-set was provided, so this school cannot be positioned against others in the county or region from the available data.
What the data does tell a parent is clear in its narrowness. This is a very small, colony-based elementary and middle school serving a tight-knit communal population, with state test results that are low and a broader information picture that is mostly empty. For families connected to the colony, the school is the local option and its character follows from that community's way of life. For anyone outside that context, there is little here to evaluate beyond the assessment numbers and the basic enrollment profile, and a direct conversation with the district would be the next step to fill in what the data does not cover.
See more original research from School Decision →