The top reported proficiency rate is 15% in English language arts. The lowest is 8% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on New Elm Spring Colony Elementary - 08
New Elm Spring Colony Elementary sits at a rural address outside Ethan, South Dakota, a very small town roughly ten miles south of Mitchell. The school is part of Parkston School District 33-3, but it operates separately from the town's main school campus on South 2nd Street. According to publicly reported information, this is a Hutterite colony school, which explains its distinct character: a very small enrollment, a single multi-grade setting serving pre-kindergarten through eighth grade, and a location on colony land rather than in town.
The enrollment is tiny, with just a handful of students per grade and a total population that would fit in a single classroom. Every student is white, and a very large share qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch. Data on English-learner status and individualized education programs was not reported, so those populations cannot be characterized here. For a school serving a Hutterite community, the absence of English-learner data may reflect reporting choices rather than the actual language environment, since many colony families speak a German dialect at home. A parent evaluating this school should keep in mind that colony schools serve a tight-knit, faith-based communal community with its own social and educational norms, and that context shapes everything from peer environment to academic expectations.
State assessment results for the most recent year are available for math and English language arts but should be read with care given the extremely small number of tested students. Math proficiency is very low, with only a single student reaching proficiency. English language arts is also low, with a similarly small count of proficient students. Science results were suppressed, likely because of the small tested group, and no average scale scores were reported for any subject. Participation was full among those tested. These proficiency levels are well below what most South Dakota schools post, and a parent may want to look into this further with the school and district to understand what instruction looks like in this setting and how the colony's language and cultural context interacts with state testing.
No multi-year trend data was available, so it is not possible to say whether these results represent a stable pattern or a recent change. The school does not serve high school grades, so no graduation rate applies. Data on staffing, attendance, discipline, course access, and Title I status was not provided, leaving a limited picture of the school's resources and day-to-day environment. No information on special programs, extracurriculars, or advanced coursework was available, which is consistent with a small colony elementary serving early and middle grades.
Ethan itself is a fully rural community with a compact footprint, a park, a few local businesses, and community clubs. Publicly reported sources describe slow, modest population growth over the past decade with recent estimates showing a slight plateau or decline. The town relies on Mitchell, ten miles north, for broader commercial and civic services. Housing in the surrounding Hutchinson County area sits below the state and national benchmarks, with a typical home value in a range that makes ownership accessible relative to many parts of the country. No rental market data was available for the immediate area.
The district brief for Parkston School District 33-3 did not surface any recent parent-relevant changes such as curriculum shifts, referendums, or facility projects, so there is little to report on the district's direction.
What this school is, in the end, is a colony elementary serving a specific religious and communal population in a rural South Dakota setting. Its academic results are weak by standard state measures, its data footprint is thin, and its purpose is tied to a community whose educational priorities may differ from those reflected in state testing. A family not part of the colony would have little reason to consider this school, and a family that is part of it will likely weigh faith, community, and tradition alongside the academic picture in a way that test scores alone cannot capture.
See more original research from School Decision →