The top reported proficiency rate is 62% in English language arts. The lowest is 40% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Rutland Elementary - 02
Rutland Elementary 02 sat at 102 School Street in the small town of Rutland, South Dakota, and operated as part of the Rutland School District 39-4. The school is now closed. Its closure followed a broader restructuring: in 2023, Rutland School District 39-4 consolidated with the neighboring Oldham-Ramona School District 39-5 to form the Oldham-Ramona-Rutland School District 39-6, redrawing governance and school sites across Lake, Kingsbury, Miner, and Moody counties. That consolidation appears to be the direct context for this school no longer operating as a standalone entity.
The newly formed district has had a turbulent early life. A 2025 referendum asked voters whether to dissolve and break up Oldham-Ramona-Rutland, and the measure was defeated by a razor-thin margin after a recount. Publicly reported coverage describes a deeply divided community over the district's future, and the outcome kept the district intact while leaving its long-term stability an open question. For any family connected to this area, that political backdrop is part of the story.
State assessment results from the 2022-23 school year, the last available window before the closure, give a picture of academic performance in the school's final operating period. Students in grades three through five took the South Dakota state assessments under SBAC for math and English language arts, and fifth graders also took the state science assessment. Participation was full across every tested group.
In English language arts, the school showed a clear upward pattern across grade levels. Third graders were proficient at a rate above half, fourth graders held in a similar range, and fifth graders reached a stronger level, with most of that cohort demonstrating proficiency. This is a encouraging trajectory in reading and writing, and the fifth-grade ELA result was the school's strongest single mark.
Math results were more mixed. Third and fourth graders landed near the midpoint, with roughly half of each cohort reaching proficiency. Fifth-grade math dropped to a lower level, where only about a third of tested students were proficient. Science results for fifth graders also sat below the midpoint. The fifth-grade math and science results are the soft spots in the available data, and a parent looking at this record historically might want to understand what instructional supports were in place for those students.
A critical caveat for all of these results is scale. Each tested cohort was very small, with just over a dozen students or fewer per grade. In groups this small, a single student's performance shifts the proficiency rate meaningfully, so these percentages reflect a handful of children rather than a broad trend. The numbers are accurate for what they measure, but they are inherently volatile.
Beyond assessment results, the data available for this school is thin. Enrollment figures, demographic breakdowns, free-or-reduced-price lunch rates, special education and English learner counts, staffing details, and disciplinary records were all missing from the sources we reviewed. We looked for community and economic context for Rutland and for locale classification information, but found none in the provided data, so we leave those gaps unnamed rather than guessing. No program offerings, course access information, or extracurricular details were available.
The school served grades that included at least third through fifth based on the tested cohorts, though the official grade range listed as a single repeated grade marker may reflect a data artifact rather than the full span. No graduation rate applies, because this was an elementary school. No comparison fact-set against neighboring districts was provided, so we cannot position this school's results relative to its county peers.
What the record leaves is a snapshot of a very small rural elementary school in its final year before district consolidation, with reasonably strong reading results in the upper grades, uneven math performance, and class sizes so small that every result is intimate rather than statistical. The school no longer operates, and families in the Rutland area now fall under the Oldham-Ramona-Rutland district, whose own future was narrowly settled by a contested vote and remains a living question.
See more original research from School Decision →