The top reported proficiency rate is 57% in Social studies. The lowest is 38% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on H. Y. Livesay Middle School
H. Y. Livesay Middle School serves fifth through eighth grade in Harrogate, a small Tennessee town shaped by its relationship with Lincoln Memorial University. The school is part of Claiborne County Schools, the single district for the county, and sits within a community where the university anchors both employment and local culture. For a family considering this school, the context matters: Harrogate has grown steadily, partly through annexation, and the district underwent a major consolidation in 2021 when all high school students were brought into one campus. That means Livesay feeds into a single high school, a straightforward path for families planning ahead.
On state assessments, the school shows a split picture. In math and English language arts, fewer than half of students reached the proficient mark. These are the subjects where a parent might want to ask the school about specific supports or interventions. Science and social studies fared better; a majority of students scored proficient, which is a genuine strength worth noting. Participation on test day was complete, so the results reflect nearly the whole student body. The school has only one year of testing data in the available sources, so no trend is visible yet.
The student body is small for a middle school spanning four grades. Racially, it is predominantly white, with a modest share of Hispanic students and very small numbers of Black, Asian, and multiracial students. Data on free or reduced-price meal eligibility, special education services, and English learner status were not reported, which is a gap a parent may want to follow up on directly with the school. No information on chronic absenteeism, discipline, or staffing was available either, so those dimensions of school life remain outside this account.
Harrogate itself gives the school a distinctive setting. It is a college town; Lincoln Memorial University runs through daily life, from its campus inside the city limits to the Abraham Lincoln Library and Museum. The built environment is oriented around the US 25E corridor rather than a walkable downtown, though there are trails and a city park. Housing values in the area fall below state and national benchmarks, which may matter for families weighing affordability. The university is the dominant employer, and the city has invested in infrastructure like a sewage treatment system as it grew. For a middle school student, the environment offers access to some cultural amenities through the university but not a dense urban fabric.
Claiborne County Schools has made several recent changes that affect middle school families. The district adopted a new English language arts curriculum for the 2023-2024 school year, focused on literacy. It also expanded career and technical education pathways in healthcare and advanced manufacturing. While these are high school programs, they signal the district’s direction and may create early awareness for middle school students. The high school consolidation means that every incoming ninth grader from Livesay will attend Claiborne County High School, located in Harrogate at the former Cumberland Gap High School campus.
For a parent, the key judgments rest on the academic data. The lower math and ELA proficiency rates are the soft spots; the higher science and social studies rates are clear strengths. The school has a small, mostly homogeneous student body in a community that is growing but still modest in scale. The college-town atmosphere is present but not dominating for a middle schooler. A family moving into the area will want to visit and ask about academic support in math and reading, as well as any missing data on economic need and special programs. The school’s size and single-feeder path to a consolidated high school make for a contained, predictable experience, which some families will value and others may find limited.
See more original research from School Decision →